Peres Steven E, Draper David O, Knight Kenneth L, Ricard Mark D
Brigham Young University, Provo, UT.
J Athl Train. 2002 Mar;37(1):43-50.
To compare the effects of 3 treatments on ankle dorsiflexion range of motion: prolonged long-duration stretching, pulsed shortwave diathermy followed by stretching, and pulsed shortwave diathermy, stretching, and ice combined. DESIGN AND SETTING: A 2 x 5 x 15 repeated-measures (on 2 factors) design guided this study. Range-of-motion change in triceps surae flexibility was the dependent variable. The 3 independent variables were treatment group, pretest and posttest measurements, and day. Treatment group had 4 levels: control, stretching (10 minutes of stretching via the weight and pulley), diathermy and stretching (20 minutes of diathermy and 10 minutes of stretching), and diathermy, stretching, and ice (20 minutes of diathermy, 10 minutes of stretching applied after 15 minutes of diathermy, and 5 minutes of ice applied during the last 5 minutes of stretching). Each subject received 14 treatments throughout 3 weeks, with a follow-up measurement taken 6 days after the last treatment. SUBJECTS: Forty-four healthy college-student volunteers not involved in any flexibility program. MEASUREMENTS: We measured ankle dorsiflexion using a digital inclinometer before and after treatment. RESULTS: After 14 days of treatment, the range-of-motion increase was greater after heat and stretching than after stretching alone. After 6 additional days of rest, the heat and stretching range-of-motion increase was greater than that for stretching alone. CONCLUSION: Pulsed shortwave diathermy application before prolonged long-duration static stretching was more effective than stretching alone in increasing flexibility throughout 3 weeks. After 14 treatments, prolonged long-duration stretching combined with pulsed shortwave diathermy followed by ice application caused greater immediate and net range-of-motion increases than prolonged long-duration stretching alone.
比较三种治疗方法对踝关节背屈活动度的影响:长时间持续拉伸、脉冲短波透热疗法后拉伸以及脉冲短波透热疗法、拉伸和冰敷联合应用。
本研究采用2×5×15重复测量(双因素)设计。腓肠肌柔韧性的活动度变化为因变量。三个自变量分别为治疗组、测试前和测试后测量以及天数。治疗组有四个水平:对照组、拉伸(通过重物和滑轮进行10分钟拉伸)、透热疗法和拉伸(20分钟透热疗法和10分钟拉伸)以及透热疗法、拉伸和冰敷(20分钟透热疗法,透热疗法15分钟后进行10分钟拉伸,在拉伸的最后5分钟进行5分钟冰敷)。每位受试者在3周内接受14次治疗,在最后一次治疗后6天进行随访测量。
44名未参与任何柔韧性训练计划的健康大学生志愿者。
在治疗前后使用数字倾角仪测量踝关节背屈。
治疗14天后,热疗和拉伸后的活动度增加幅度大于单纯拉伸。在额外休息6天后,热疗和拉伸后的活动度增加幅度大于单纯拉伸。
在长时间静态拉伸前应用脉冲短波透热疗法在增加3周内的柔韧性方面比单纯拉伸更有效。经过14次治疗后,长时间持续拉伸联合脉冲短波透热疗法后冰敷比单纯长时间持续拉伸导致更大的即时和净活动度增加。