Ulrich Jana, Maxeiner Helmut
Institut für Rechtsmedizin, Freien Universität Berlin.
Arch Kriminol. 2003 Jul-Aug;212(1-2):19-29.
Bite marks of the tongue are often associated with epileptic seizures, although information about the real frequency of bite marks of the tongue is hard to find. This is also true for their presence in deaths of epileptics or in deaths in general. The purpose of this investigation was to analyze the frequency of bite marks of the tongue in deaths of epileptics in comparison to a control group. Further points of interest were the spectrum of the causes of death recorded, toxicological data as well as the presence and localization of external head injuries. The study group consisted of 105 individuals with a known history of epilepsy, the control group of 107 individuals with sudden cardiac death. Autopsy reports were analyzed retrospectively. In the first group bite marks of the tongue were seen in 21% (in the subgroup "observed death during seizure" even in 64%) and were thus significantly more frequent than in the control group (2%). In 35 cases of the study material an unnatural manner of death was found (trauma, especially craniocerebral trauma, drowning, asphyxia, intoxication) and in 70 cases a natural death was assumed. However, in 41 of these the exact cause of death was not ascertainable. According to the SUDEP criteria (Ficker 2000, Nilsson 1999) 29 of these cases could be categorized as possible or probable SUDEP (sudden unexpected death in epilepsy) with 17 showing bite marks of the tongue. The fact that half of the remaining 12 cases showed bite marks of the tongue suggests at least for these cases that death occurred during the seizure. Head injuries were reported in 41% of the epilepsy group--in the subgroup "observed death during seizure" in 73%. Our investigation did not produce evidence for a higher frequency of bite marks of the tongue in cases in which resuscitation had been attempted. In our experience the presence of fresh bite marks of the tongue--according to histological findings--is a useful signs for the assignment of death to an epileptic seizure and especially for death during acute convulsion.
舌咬伤常与癫痫发作相关,尽管关于舌咬伤实际发生率的信息很难找到。在癫痫患者死亡或一般死亡病例中,情况亦是如此。本调查的目的是分析癫痫患者死亡时舌咬伤的发生率,并与对照组进行比较。其他关注点包括记录的死亡原因谱、毒理学数据以及头部外伤的存在和定位。研究组由105名有癫痫病史的个体组成,对照组由107名心脏性猝死个体组成。对尸检报告进行回顾性分析。在第一组中,21%的病例出现舌咬伤(在“发作时观察到死亡”的亚组中,这一比例甚至达到64%),因此明显高于对照组(2%)。在研究材料的35例病例中,发现有非自然死亡方式(外伤,尤其是颅脑外伤、溺水、窒息、中毒),70例被认为是自然死亡。然而,其中41例的确切死亡原因无法确定。根据癫痫性猝死标准(Ficker 2000,Nilsson 1999),这些病例中有29例可归类为可能或很可能的癫痫性猝死(SUDEP)(突然意外癫痫死亡),其中17例有舌咬伤。其余12例中有一半出现舌咬伤,这表明至少对于这些病例,死亡发生在癫痫发作期间。癫痫组中有41%报告有头部外伤——在“发作时观察到死亡”的亚组中,这一比例为73%。我们的调查没有发现证据表明在尝试进行复苏的病例中舌咬伤的发生率更高。根据我们的经验,根据组织学发现,新鲜舌咬伤的存在是将死亡归因于癫痫发作尤其是急性惊厥时死亡的有用体征。