Koh Jae O, Cassidy J David, Watkinson E Jane
Faculty of Physical Education and Recreation, University of Alberta, Edmonton, Canada.
Brain Inj. 2003 Oct;17(10):901-17. doi: 10.1080/0269905031000088869.
To estimate incidence of concussion in contact sports.
Systematic review of the literature on concussion in contact sports.
MEDLINE was searched from 1985-2000. Older articles cited in retrieved articles were also reviewed. Articles meeting the inclusion/exclusion criteria were critically appraised for methodologic quality. The incidence of concussion was recalculated in some cases.
Twenty-three out of 63 identified articles were accepted to estimate the risk of concussion. Overall, ice hockey and rugby have the highest incidence of concussion and soccer has the lowest. Male boxers and female taekwondo participants have the highest frequency of concussion at the recreational level.
There are few good studies on the incidence of concussion and limited information on the risk of concussion for females in contact sports. Some common methodological problems were also identified in this literature with the hope of improving future studies.
评估接触性运动中脑震荡的发生率。
对接触性运动中脑震荡的文献进行系统综述。
检索1985年至2000年的MEDLINE数据库。对检索到的文章中引用的更早的文章也进行了综述。对符合纳入/排除标准的文章进行方法学质量的严格评估。在某些情况下重新计算了脑震荡的发生率。
63篇已识别的文章中有23篇被纳入以评估脑震荡风险。总体而言,冰球和橄榄球的脑震荡发生率最高,足球的发生率最低。在娱乐层面,男性拳击手和女性跆拳道参与者的脑震荡发生率最高。
关于脑震荡发生率的高质量研究较少,接触性运动中女性脑震荡风险的信息有限。在该文献中还发现了一些常见的方法学问题,希望能改进未来的研究。