Salmon Margaret, Abel Kathryn, Cordingley Lis, Friedman Trevor, Appleby Louis
Centre for Women's Mental Health Research, School of Psychiatry and Behavioural Sciences, University of Manchester, UK.
Aust N Z J Psychiatry. 2003 Oct;37(5):556-62. doi: 10.1046/j.1440-1614.2003.01253.x.
To examine maternal clinical and parenting outcomes as a function of diagnosis following joint mother-baby admission; to identify the associations of poor outcome.
Demographic and clinical information was collected on 1081 joint mother-baby admissions, including 224 women with schizophrenia, 155 with bipolar disorder and 409 with non-psychotic depression. Information was based on clinical judgements of senior staff in participating units using the Marcé checklist. Predictors of poor maternal clinical outcome, practical problems in baby care, poor emotional responsiveness to infant and perceived risk of harm to baby were identified by logistic regression.
Good clinical outcome was reported in 848 (78%) cases. On each parenting outcome, good outcome was reported in at least 80%. The predictors of poor outcome were similar for all four outcomes. These were a diagnosis of schizophrenia, behavioural disturbance, low social class and either psychiatric illness in the woman's partner or a poor relationship with the partner. Of those with poor outcome on all four variables, 66% suffered with schizophrenia. Women with schizophrenia showed more behavioural disturbance, were more likely to experience hallucinations and delusions, and were more likely to be of low social class. They were also less likely to have a partner and more likely to have a partner with a psychiatric illness.
Clinical and parenting outcomes, as reported by clinical staff, are usually good following joint mother-baby admission. Women with schizophrenia may need particular measures to improve their parenting. A marital approach to treatment, directed at the woman's relationship with her partner or the latter's own mental health may improve outcome.
探讨母婴联合入院后母亲的临床及养育结局与诊断之间的关系;确定不良结局的相关因素。
收集了1081例母婴联合入院病例的人口统计学和临床信息,其中包括224例精神分裂症女性、155例双相情感障碍女性和409例非精神病性抑郁症女性。信息基于参与单位高级工作人员使用Marcé清单做出的临床判断。通过逻辑回归确定母亲临床结局不良、婴儿护理中的实际问题、对婴儿情感反应不佳以及对婴儿造成伤害的感知风险的预测因素。
848例(78%)报告临床结局良好。在各项养育结局方面,至少80%报告结局良好。所有四项结局不良的预测因素相似。这些因素包括精神分裂症诊断、行为障碍、社会阶层低以及女性伴侣患有精神疾病或与伴侣关系不佳。在所有四个变量结局不良的患者中,66%患有精神分裂症。患有精神分裂症的女性表现出更多的行为障碍,更有可能出现幻觉和妄想,且更有可能属于低社会阶层。她们也不太可能有伴侣,且伴侣患有精神疾病的可能性更大。
临床工作人员报告的临床及养育结局在母婴联合入院后通常良好。患有精神分裂症的女性可能需要采取特殊措施来改善其养育能力。针对女性与其伴侣关系或伴侣自身心理健康的婚姻治疗方法可能会改善结局。