Semrau Sabine, Bier Anette, Thierbach Ulrike, Virchow Christian, Ketterer Peter, Fietkau Rainer
Department of Radiotherapy, Rostock University, Rostock, Germany.
Strahlenther Onkol. 2003 Dec;179(12):823-31. doi: 10.1007/s00066-003-1127-8.
In elderly patients, patients with multiple morbidities, and patients with a reduced general condition, the standard treatment of inoperable non-small-cell lung cancer (NSCLC) consists of either chemotherapy or radiation therapy alone and is associated with an extremely poor prognosis. We therefore investigated the feasibility, toxicity, and efficacy of radiotherapy with concurrent chemotherapy using vinorelbine plus cisplatin or carboplatin in NSCLC patients at risk for treatment complications.
A total of 33 patients (six women, 27 men, median age 65 years) with locally advanced, functionally inoperable pulmonary carcinomas, recurrent lung cancer or postoperative macroscopic residual tumors (R2) with an increased risk of treatment complications (WHO performance status 2/3; cardiac, renal or pulmonary failure; marked pretherapeutic weight loss; age between 71-75 years) received 12.5 mg of vinorelbine per m(2) body surface area (BSA) on days 1, 8, 15, 29, 36 and 43 plus either cisplatin 20 mg/m(2) BSA (ten patients) or carboplatin 70 mg/m(2) BSA (23 patients) on days 1-5 and 29-33 together with conventionally fractionated radiotherapy. The tumor regions were irradiated with doses of up to 63 Gy (90% isodose), and potentially affected lymph nodes received doses of up to 45.0 or 50.4 Gy (90% isodose).
Briefly, 31 of 33 patients successfully completed radiation therapy and 26 received four cycles of vinorelbine plus at least two cycles of cisplatin or carboplatin. Hematotoxic side effects included grade III leukocytopenia (n = 8), grade III thrombocytopenia (n = 5), and grade IV thrombocytopenia (n = 2). Other side effects consisted of peripheral neuropathy grade III (n = 1) and esophagitis grade IV (n = 1). Severe pneumonitis did not occur. Six patients had pneumonia before radiochemotherapy. 21 patients (63%) exhibited a complete (n = 7) or partial response (n = 14) to chemoradiation. The twelve nonresponders had either stable (n = 9) or progressive disease (n = 3). The survival rates plus standard deviations were as follows: 1-year survival: 60 +/- 8%, 2-year survival: 36 +/- 9%, 3-year survival: 24 +/- 9%, median survival time: 17 months (5;29 months; 95% confidence interval [CI]), median progression-free survival: 11 months (9;13 months; 95% CI). The median follow-up time was 14 months.
Conventionally fractionated radiochemotherapy with vinorelbine plus a platinum derivative is feasible in patients with NSCLC and increased risk of treatment complications. Compared to patient populations described in the literature, the survival rates achieved by concurrent radiochemotherapy appear to be better than those achieved with radiotherapy alone.
在老年患者、患有多种疾病的患者以及一般状况较差的患者中,无法手术的非小细胞肺癌(NSCLC)的标准治疗仅包括化疗或放疗,且预后极差。因此,我们研究了长春瑞滨联合顺铂或卡铂同步化疗在有治疗并发症风险的NSCLC患者中进行放疗的可行性、毒性和疗效。
共有33例患者(6例女性,27例男性,中位年龄65岁),患有局部晚期、功能上无法手术的肺癌、复发性肺癌或术后肉眼可见残留肿瘤(R2),且有治疗并发症风险增加(世界卫生组织体能状态2/3;心脏、肾脏或肺部衰竭;治疗前体重明显减轻;年龄在71 - 75岁之间),在第1、8、15、29、36和43天接受每平方米体表面积(BSA)12.5 mg长春瑞滨,在第1 - 5天和第29 - 33天联合顺铂20 mg/m² BSA(10例患者)或卡铂70 mg/m² BSA(23例患者),同时进行常规分割放疗。肿瘤区域接受高达63 Gy(90%等剂量线)的照射,潜在受影响的淋巴结接受高达45.0或50.4 Gy(90%等剂量线)的照射。
简要来说,33例患者中有31例成功完成放疗,26例接受了四个周期的长春瑞滨加至少两个周期的顺铂或卡铂治疗。血液毒性副作用包括III级白细胞减少(n = 8)、III级血小板减少(n = 5)和IV级血小板减少(n = 2)。其他副作用包括III级周围神经病变(n = 1)和IV级食管炎(n = 1)。未发生严重肺炎。6例患者在放化疗前患有肺炎。21例患者(63%)对放化疗表现出完全缓解(n = 7)或部分缓解(n = 14)。12例无反应者病情稳定(n = 9)或进展(n = 3)。生存率及标准差如下:1年生存率:60±8%,2年生存率:36±9%,3年生存率:24±9%,中位生存时间:17个月(5;29个月;95%置信区间[CI]),中位无进展生存期:11个月(9;13个月;95% CI)。中位随访时间为14个月。
长春瑞滨联合铂类衍生物进行常规分割放化疗在有治疗并发症风险增加的NSCLC患者中是可行的。与文献中描述的患者群体相比,同步放化疗所达到的生存率似乎优于单纯放疗所达到的生存率。