Macinko James A, Shi Leiyu, Starfield Barbara, Wulu John T
New York University, Steinhardt School of Education, USA.
Med Care Res Rev. 2003 Dec;60(4):407-52. doi: 10.1177/1077558703257169.
This article critically reviews published literature on the relationship between income inequality and health outcomes. Studies are systematically assessed in terms of design, data quality, measures, health outcomes, and covariates analyzed. At least 33 studies indicate a significant association between income inequality and health outcomes, while at least 12 studies do not find such an association. Inconsistencies include the following: (1) the model of health determinants is different in nearly every study, (2) income inequality measures and data are inconsistent, (3) studies are performed on different combinations of countries and/or states, (4) the time period in which studies are conducted is not consistent, and (5) health outcome measures differ. The relationship between income inequality and health is unclear. Future studies will require a more comprehensive model of health production that includes health system covariates, sufficient sample size, and adjustment for inconsistencies in income inequality data.
本文批判性地回顾了已发表的关于收入不平等与健康结果之间关系的文献。从研究设计、数据质量、测量方法、健康结果以及所分析的协变量等方面对各项研究进行了系统评估。至少33项研究表明收入不平等与健康结果之间存在显著关联,而至少12项研究未发现这种关联。不一致之处包括:(1)几乎每项研究中健康决定因素的模型都不同;(2)收入不平等的测量方法和数据不一致;(3)研究是在不同的国家和/或州的组合上进行的;(4)开展研究的时间段不一致;(5)健康结果的测量方法不同。收入不平等与健康之间的关系尚不清楚。未来的研究将需要一个更全面的健康生产模型,该模型应包括卫生系统协变量、足够的样本量以及对收入不平等数据不一致性的调整。