Franchi F, Michelucci A, Padeletti L, Monopoli A, Fabbri G, Cersosimo R M, Mezzani A
Clinica Medica II, Università degli Studi di Firenze.
G Ital Cardiol. 1992 Aug;22(8):905-18.
Several studies have evidenced that hypertensive patients (pts) with left ventricular hypertrophy (LVH) have an increased incidence of malignant ventricular arrhythmias and sudden death. The purpose of our study was to investigate the prevalence of risky ventricular arrhythmias in uncomplicated hypertensive pts (untreated during last 10 days) in comparison with normotensive ones. In this context, not only the value of left ventricular mass index (LVMI) was taken into account, but also the type of LVH and the related functional behaviour.
59 untreated mild to moderate essential hypertensives (EH), without symptoms or signs of coronary artery disease, were classified in 3 groups: normal (i.e. without hypertrophy) EH (NEH: 12 pts, 6 M and 6 F, mean age +/- SD 52 +/- 10 yrs), concentric hypertrophic EH (CEH: 30 pts, 15 M and 15 F, mean age +/- SD 59 +/- 10 yrs), and eccentric hypertrophic EH (EEH: 17 pts, 7 M and 10F, mean age +/- SD 60 +/- 10 yrs), according to echocardiographic measurements. Values and duration of arterial hypertension were comparable among the groups. A normotensive, age-matched group was studied as control (C: 21 pts, 11 M and 10 F, mean age +/- SD, 57 +/- 10 yrs). 24-hour Holter electrocardiographic monitoring (ECG-H) and Signal-Averaged electrocardiography (SAECG) were performed seeking to identify the arrhythmogenic risk. Echocardiographic analysis was accomplished by means of a computerized system: LVMI, ratio of LV wall thickness to LV internal radius (relative wall thickness = RWTh), systolic velocity of circumferential fractioning (VCFs), peak of LV relaxation rate (pLVRr) and peak-systolic stress (pSS) were evaluated.
Normal LV systolic function was generally found, but both NEH and EEH groups showed a significant reduction in pLVRr in comparison with C and CEH groups (mean values +/- SD: 3.52 +/- 1,3 and 3.40 +/- 0.9 vs 4.92 +/- 0.4 and 4.27 +/- 1.4 sec-1, respectively, p < .05 for both). pSS was significantly higher in EEH and NEH than in CEH and C (mean values +/- SD: 149 +/- 42 and 157 +/- 66 vs 116 +/- 28 and 122 +/- 15 10(3) dynes/cm2, respectively; p < .05 for both). At ECG-H, EEH had a prevalence of potentially malignant ventricular arrhythmias (PMVA: ventricular extrasystoles > or = 30/h; ventricular couplets, > or = 2 episodes/24h, or triplets, > or = 1 episode/24h; R on T), significantly larger than in C (35.3% vs 4.8%, p < .05) and almost significantly larger than in NEH and CEH (8.3% and 10%, respectively). No differences in LVMI were found between EEH with or without PMVA. In respect of functional LV behaviour, the former group showed lower values of VCFs (2.33 +/- 0.6 vs 3.71 +/- 1.32 sec-1, (p < .005) than the latter group. At SAECG, the EEH exhibited again a greater prevalence of abnormal findings than C (35.3% vs 0%, p < 0.5). No correlations were found between ECG-H and SAECG abnormalities, nor between the latter group and LVMI or LV functional indexes. Among pts showing a more pronounced impairment of diastolic function (pLVRr < 4 sec-1), EEH exhibited the highest prevalence of both PMVA (50%) and late potentials (41%).
Our data suggest that uncomplicated mild to moderate essential hypertension may be associated with higher risk of ventricular arrhythmias, particularly when cardiac involvement is characterized by eccentric LVH. On the contrary, in this stage of hypertensive disease, LVMI as well as LV function do not seem to influence the ventricular arrhythmogenesis. The clinical importance of these findings is uncertain, and further studies are needed.
多项研究证明,患有左心室肥厚(LVH)的高血压患者发生恶性室性心律失常和猝死的几率增加。我们研究的目的是调查单纯性高血压患者(过去10天未接受治疗)与血压正常者相比,发生危险性室性心律失常的情况。在此背景下,不仅考虑了左心室质量指数(LVMI)的值,还考虑了LVH的类型及相关功能表现。
59例未经治疗的轻至中度原发性高血压(EH)患者,无冠状动脉疾病的症状或体征,根据超声心动图测量结果分为3组:正常(即无肥厚)EH患者(NEH:12例,男6例,女6例,平均年龄±标准差52±10岁)、向心性肥厚EH患者(CEH:30例,男15例,女15例,平均年龄±标准差59±10岁)和离心性肥厚EH患者(EEH:17例,男7例,女10例,平均年龄±标准差60±10岁)。各组间动脉高血压的数值和病程具有可比性。选取年龄匹配的血压正常组作为对照(C组:21例,男11例,女10例,平均年龄±标准差57±10岁)。进行24小时动态心电图监测(ECG-H)和信号平均心电图(SAECG)检查以确定心律失常风险。通过计算机系统进行超声心动图分析:评估LVMI、左心室壁厚度与左心室内径之比(相对壁厚度=RWTh)、圆周缩短分数的收缩速度(VCFs)、左心室舒张速率峰值(pLVRr)和收缩期峰值应力(pSS)。
总体上左心室收缩功能正常,但NEH组和EEH组与C组和CEH组相比,pLVRr显著降低(平均值±标准差:分别为3.52±1.3和3.40±0.9,对比4.92±0.4和4.27±1.4秒-1,两组均p<0.05)。EEH组和NEH组的pSS显著高于CEH组和C组(平均值±标准差:分别为149±42和157±66,对比116±28和122±15 10³达因/平方厘米,两组均p<0.05)。在ECG-H检查中,EEH组潜在恶性室性心律失常(PMVA:室性早搏≥30次/小时;室性成对早搏,≥2次发作/24小时,或室性三联律,≥1次发作/24小时;R波落在T波上)的发生率显著高于C组(35.3%对比4.8%,p<0.05),几乎显著高于NEH组和CEH组(分别为8.3%和10%)。有无PMVA的EEH组之间LVMI无差异。就左心室功能表现而言,前一组的VCFs值低于后一组(2.33±0.6对比3.71±1.32秒-1,p<0.005)。在SAECG检查中,EEH组异常结果发生率再次高于C组(35.3%对比0%,p<0.5)。未发现ECG-H与SAECG异常之间、后一组与LVMI或左心室功能指标之间存在相关性。在舒张功能损害更明显(pLVRr<4秒-1)的患者中,EEH组PMVA(50%)和晚电位(41%)的发生率最高。
我们的数据表明,单纯性轻至中度原发性高血压可能与较高的室性心律失常风险相关,尤其是当心脏受累表现为离心性LVH时。相反,但在高血压疾病的这个阶段,LVMI以及左心室功能似乎并不影响室性心律失常的发生。这些发现的临床重要性尚不确定,需要进一步研究。