Chatwani A, Yazigi R, Amin-Hanjani S
Temple University School of Medicine, Department of Obstetrics, Gynecology & Reproductive Sciences, Philadelphia, PA.
J Laparoendosc Surg. 1992 Dec;2(6):319-24. doi: 10.1089/lps.1992.2.319.
One hundred and seventeen consecutive patients with diagnosis of ectopic pregnancy admitted to Temple University Hospital between October 1989 and March 1992 were divided into two groups. Group 1 consisted of 56 patients with operative laparoscopy and Group 2 consisted of 61 patients treated by laparotomy. The two groups were similar for age, race, parity, gestation, presentation, and location of the ectopic gestations. Fifty seven percent of patients in the laparoscopy group were treated by salpingectomy and 43% by salpingostomy, compared to 84% and 16% respectively in the laparotomy group. Mean operative time for laparoscopy was 58 min and 42 min for laparotomy. Complication rates were similar in the two sub-groups. Only two patients in the laparoscopy group required subsequent laparotomy, one to assure hemostasis and one, 5 weeks following surgery, for persistent trophoblastic disease. Operative laparoscopy was associated with a significantly shorter length of hospital stay (1.25 v. 4.39 days). This reflected in a lower cost of hospital stay ($10,105 vs. $13,608). The present data demonstrates that operative laparoscopy is not only safe and effective, but also more economical than open laparotomy in the treatment of ectopic pregnancies. This procedure is expected to replace laparotomy for the treatment of most cases of tubal ectopic pregnancy.
1989年10月至1992年3月期间,连续117例被诊断为异位妊娠并入住坦普尔大学医院的患者被分为两组。第一组由56例行手术腹腔镜检查的患者组成,第二组由61例行剖腹手术的患者组成。两组患者在年龄、种族、产次、孕周、临床表现和异位妊娠部位方面相似。腹腔镜检查组中57%的患者接受了输卵管切除术,43%接受了输卵管造口术,而剖腹手术组分别为84%和16%。腹腔镜检查的平均手术时间为58分钟,剖腹手术为42分钟。两个亚组的并发症发生率相似。腹腔镜检查组中只有两名患者需要随后进行剖腹手术,一名是为了确保止血,另一名是在手术后5周因持续性滋养细胞疾病进行手术。手术腹腔镜检查与显著缩短的住院时间相关(1.25天对4.39天)。这反映在较低的住院费用上(10105美元对13608美元)。目前的数据表明,手术腹腔镜检查在治疗异位妊娠方面不仅安全有效,而且比开放剖腹手术更经济。预计该手术将取代剖腹手术用于治疗大多数输卵管异位妊娠病例。