Seror V, Moatti J P, Muller F, Le Gales C, Boue A
INSERM, Unité 357 Recherche en Economie de la Santé, Salle Déjerine, Hôpital de Bicêtre, Le Kremlin-Bicêtre.
J Gynecol Obstet Biol Reprod (Paris). 1992;21(8):915-22.
Introduction of maternal serum markers for prenatal screening of Down's syndrome leads to a redefinition of the criteria used for identifying at risk women (i.e. in France, mainly based on maternal age of 38 and over). Effectiveness and costs of prenatal screening of Down's syndrome using such maternal serum markers will vary depending on the biological cut-off values defined, at each maternal age, to identify the population of pregnant women that will be sent to amniocentesis. On the basis of the first French prospective study of the use of human chorionic gonadotropin (hCG) measurement in maternal serum as a predictor of an increased risk of Down's syndrome, this paper shows that a screening policy combining maternal age with hCG measurement is more cost-effective than screening on the basis of maternal age alone. However, final decisions about hCG cut-off values should take into account the complex ethical dilemmas involved, especially the potential consequences of "false positives" and "false negatives", of this marker.
引入用于唐氏综合征产前筛查的母体血清标志物,导致对识别高危女性所使用标准的重新定义(即,在法国,主要基于38岁及以上的母亲年龄)。使用此类母体血清标志物进行唐氏综合征产前筛查的有效性和成本,将取决于在每个母亲年龄所定义的生物临界值,以确定将被送去做羊膜穿刺术的孕妇群体。基于法国首次关于在母体血清中测量人绒毛膜促性腺激素(hCG)作为唐氏综合征风险增加预测指标的前瞻性研究,本文表明,将母亲年龄与hCG测量相结合的筛查策略比仅基于母亲年龄进行筛查更具成本效益。然而,关于hCG临界值的最终决策应考虑其中涉及的复杂伦理困境,尤其是该标志物“假阳性”和“假阴性”的潜在后果。