Ell S R, Parker A J
ENT Department, Royal Hallamshire Hospital, Sheffield, UK.
Clin Otolaryngol Allied Sci. 1992 Dec;17(6):514-6. doi: 10.1111/j.1365-2273.1992.tb01708.x.
Plain radiographs are often taken to localize fishbones which lodge in the pharynx. In this study a pig's neck was used to determine the radio-opacity of 14 different species of fishbones. Radiographs were taken with bones placed in up to four of the common sites of impaction and assessed on two occasions independently by two previously uninvolved ENT consultants. The visibility of the fishbones was scored. Inter and intra-observer agreement for species and site was determined. There was excellent interobserver agreement at both sessions for species (rs1 = 0.96, P < 0.0001, rs2 = 0.95, P < 0.0001) and site (rs1 = 0.98, P < 0.05, rs2 = 0.95, P congruent to 0.05). Intraobserver agreement for species of fish were similarly significant but not for site. The most opaque bones were cod, haddock, grey mullet and lemon sole. The site most often detected was the laryngopharynx and that most often missed was the tonsil. This study is clinically relevant because it is useful to know which species of fishbone are radio-opaque when clinical examination fails to reveal a foreign body and may clarify the decision to proceed to endoscopy.
通常会拍摄普通X光片来确定卡在咽部的鱼刺位置。在本研究中,使用猪的颈部来测定14种不同种类鱼刺的不透射线程度。将鱼刺放置在多达四个常见的卡刺部位后拍摄X光片,并由两名之前未参与的耳鼻喉科会诊医生独立进行两次评估。对鱼刺的可见度进行评分。确定了观察者间和观察者内对鱼刺种类和位置的一致性。在两个阶段,观察者间对鱼刺种类(rs1 = 0.96,P < 0.0001,rs2 = 0.95,P < 0.0001)和位置(rs1 = 0.98,P < 0.05,rs2 = 0.95,P ≈ 0.05)的一致性都非常好。观察者内对鱼刺种类的一致性同样显著,但对位置的一致性不显著。不透射线程度最高的鱼刺是鳕鱼、黑线鳕、乌鱼和柠檬鲽。最常检测到鱼刺的部位是下咽,最常漏检的部位是扁桃体。这项研究具有临床相关性,因为当临床检查未能发现异物时,了解哪些种类的鱼刺不透射线是有用的,并且可能有助于明确是否进行内窥镜检查的决定。