van Hasselt Piet, Gudde Hugo
Ear Clinic, Bamalete Lutheran Hospital, Ramotswa, Botswana.
J Laryngol Otol. 2004 Feb;118(2):93-6. doi: 10.1258/002221504772784513.
Otitis externa (OE) and especially otomycosis can be very persistent and difficult to control. In the present study the efficacy of treatment of OE with a single instillation in the ear canal of one per cent silver nitrate in three per cent hypromellose gel compared to 0.1 per cent silver nitrate gel was tested in a single-blinded randomized controlled parallel group study. The outcome measure was complete resolution of the OE after one week. Forty-four patients with refractory, bacterial as well as fungal, OE entered the study, comprising 30 ears in each treatment arm. Eight patients defaulted from follow-up, five ears in each treatment arm. A single instillation of one per cent silver nitrate gel cured 23 (92 per cent) of 25 ears with OE, whereas with 0.1 per cent silver nitrate gel seven (28 per cent) of 25 ears treated were cured (Fisher-exact test, p-exact = 0.00010). In a non-controlled series of 120 ears 93.3 per cent needed only a single instillation of one per cent silver nitrate gel while another five per cent were cured after a second instillation a week later. There were no adverse reactions. OE can be treated effectively with instillation of one per cent silver nitrate gel and is particularly useful in recalcitrant otomycosis. The treatment method saves both cost and time.
外耳道炎(OE)尤其是耳真菌病可能非常顽固且难以控制。在本研究中,在一项单盲随机对照平行组研究中,测试了在耳道内单次滴注1%硝酸银于3%羟丙甲纤维素凝胶中治疗OE的疗效,并与0.1%硝酸银凝胶进行比较。结局指标是一周后OE完全消退。44例难治性细菌性和真菌性OE患者进入研究,每个治疗组有30只耳朵。8例患者失访,每个治疗组各有5只耳朵。单次滴注1%硝酸银凝胶治愈了25只患有OE耳朵中的23只(92%),而0.1%硝酸银凝胶治疗的25只耳朵中7只(28%)被治愈(Fisher精确检验,精确p值 = 0.00010)。在120只耳朵的非对照系列中,93.3%的耳朵仅需单次滴注1%硝酸银凝胶,另外5%在一周后第二次滴注后治愈。没有不良反应。OE可以通过滴注1%硝酸银凝胶有效治疗,在顽固性耳真菌病中特别有用。该治疗方法节省成本和时间。