Sittiwangkul Rekwan, Azakie Anthony, Van Arsdell Glen S, Williams William G, McCrindle Brian W
Departments of Pediatrics and Surgery, Divisions of Cardiology and Cardiovascular Surgery, The Hospital for Sick Children, University of Toronto School of Medicine, Toronto, Ontario, Canada.
Ann Thorac Surg. 2004 Mar;77(3):889-94. doi: 10.1016/j.athoracsur.2003.09.027.
Whereas indications expand and results improve with increasing refinements to the Fontan procedure the overall impact on outcomes related to tricuspid atresia remains suboptimally defined.
We reviewed 225 consecutive patients presenting between 1971 and 1999. All patients had classic tricuspid atresia with absent right atrioventricular connection and with D-transposition of the great arteries in 21%, pulmonary outflow obstruction in 75%, and aortic outflow obstruction in 11%.
Ten patients died before any intervention and 3 patients were lost to follow-up. Palliative procedures (includes 151 with systemic shunt, 27 pulmonary artery banding, 60 venous shunt) were performed in 203 patients, with 44 deaths, 8 patients awaiting Fontan, 12 patients Fontan contraindicated, and 11 patients lost-to-follow-up. A total of 137 patients had the Fontan procedure (9 patients without previous procedures) with 7 early deaths, 11 late deaths, and 3 patients progressing to heart transplantation. Total survival for the cohort was 90% at the age of 1 month, 81% at 1 year, 70% at 10 years, and 60% at 20 years with no significant change over the time period. Independent factors associated with ineligibility or death without Fontan (n = 68, 30%) included earlier birth date, lower birth weight, presence of aortic arch anomaly and greater right ventricular hypoplasia, and no palliative procedure. There were no significant changes in mortality with Fontan over the study time period with survival of 95% at 1 month, 93% at 1year, and 82% at 10 years.
Improvements in outcomes with tricuspid atresia will require attention to management and risk factors before Fontan.
随着Fontan手术的不断完善,其适应证不断扩大,效果也有所改善,但对三尖瓣闭锁相关结局的总体影响仍未得到充分明确。
我们回顾了1971年至1999年间连续就诊的225例患者。所有患者均为典型三尖瓣闭锁,右房室连接缺如,21%合并大动脉D型转位,75%合并肺动脉流出道梗阻,11%合并主动脉流出道梗阻。
10例患者在接受任何干预前死亡,3例患者失访。203例患者接受了姑息性手术(包括151例体肺分流术、27例肺动脉环缩术、60例静脉分流术),其中44例死亡,8例等待Fontan手术,12例Fontan手术禁忌,11例失访。共有137例患者接受了Fontan手术(9例未接受过先前手术),其中7例早期死亡,11例晚期死亡,3例进展为心脏移植。该队列在1个月时的总生存率为90%,1岁时为81%,10岁时为70%,20岁时为60%,在此期间无显著变化。与未行Fontan手术而不符合条件或死亡相关的独立因素(n = 68,30%)包括出生日期较早、出生体重较低、存在主动脉弓异常和右心室发育不全程度较重,以及未行姑息性手术。在研究期间,Fontan手术后的死亡率无显著变化,1个月时生存率为95%,1岁时为93%,10岁时为82%。
改善三尖瓣闭锁的结局需要关注Fontan手术前的管理和危险因素。