Pikal Michael J, Chang Liuquan Lucy, Tang Xiaolin Charlie
School of Pharmacy, University of Connecticut, 372 Fairfield Road, Storrs, Connecticut 06269-2092, USA.
J Pharm Sci. 2004 Apr;93(4):981-94. doi: 10.1002/jps.10582.
The purpose of this study is to investigate the quantitative relationship between the width of the glass transition, DeltaTg, and glass fragility or activation energy for structural relaxation. The ultimate objective is the estimation of structural relaxation time as a function of temperature from the width of the glass transition region, allowing characterization of glass dynamics by a single simple measurement. The Moynihan correlation indicates that activation energy for structural relaxation should be inversely proportional to the width of the glass transition, but recent experimental studies suggest this relationship is a poor approximation for glasses of pharmaceutical interest. The present study is an effort to better understand the validity of the Moynihan correlation by selected experimental studies and a theoretical analysis of those factors that impact the glass transition width. Experimental data for glass transition widths for (poly)vinylpyrrolidone, sucrose, and trehalose are obtained using a variety of procedures, and relaxation time data are obtained using the thermal activity monitor. The theoretical analysis begins by simulating the temperature dependence of the heat capacity by breaking the cooling and heating scans into a large number of temperature steps followed by isothermal holds, during which relaxation of the material is calculated. Here, the modified VTF equation is used for relaxation time and the generalized Kohlraush-Williams-Watts stretched exponential function is used to describe the relaxation kinetics. Simulations are performed for materials of varying fragility and varying "stretched exponential" constants, beta, and the width of the glass transition region, DeltaTg, is evaluated from the simulated heat capacity versus temperature curves as one would do with experimental data. Agreement between the theoretical simulations and experimental DeltaTg data is excellent. The simulations demonstrate that although the Moynihan correlation is not valid for variable beta, a modification of the Moynihan correlation which includes variation in beta is a good approximation. Thus, an estimate of fragility may be obtained from glass transition width data provided an estimate of beta is available. Furthermore, it is shown that a first approximation for beta may be obtained from the magnitude (i.e., height) of the differential scanning calorimetry thermal overshoot. We also find that using the modified VTF equation to evaluate the temperature dependence of the structural relaxation time at the glass transition, and integrating this expression to lower temperatures, it is possible to obtain an evaluation of the relaxation time constant, tau(beta), in the glass at any temperature, using only the DeltaTg and beta values obtained from a single differential scanning calorimetry scan. These estimated time constants correlate very well with the values directly measured with the thermal activity monitor.
本研究的目的是探究玻璃化转变宽度(ΔTg)与玻璃脆性或结构弛豫活化能之间的定量关系。最终目标是根据玻璃化转变区域的宽度估算结构弛豫时间随温度的变化,从而通过单一简单测量来表征玻璃动力学。莫伊尼汉相关性表明,结构弛豫活化能应与玻璃化转变宽度成反比,但最近的实验研究表明,这种关系对于具有药学意义的玻璃来说是一个很差的近似。本研究旨在通过选定的实验研究以及对影响玻璃化转变宽度的因素进行理论分析,更好地理解莫伊尼汉相关性的有效性。使用多种方法获得了(聚)乙烯基吡咯烷酮、蔗糖和海藻糖的玻璃化转变宽度的实验数据,并使用热活性监测仪获得了弛豫时间数据。理论分析首先通过将冷却和加热扫描分解为大量温度步长,随后进行等温保持,在此期间计算材料的弛豫,来模拟热容的温度依赖性。在这里,修正的VTF方程用于弛豫时间,广义科尔劳施 - 威廉姆斯 - 瓦特拉伸指数函数用于描述弛豫动力学。对不同脆性和不同“拉伸指数”常数β的材料进行了模拟,并像处理实验数据一样从模拟的热容与温度曲线评估玻璃化转变区域的宽度ΔTg。理论模拟与实验ΔTg数据之间的一致性非常好。模拟表明,虽然莫伊尼汉相关性对于可变的β无效,但包含β变化的莫伊尼汉相关性的修正却是一个很好的近似。因此,如果可以获得β的估计值,那么可以从玻璃化转变宽度数据中获得脆性的估计值。此外,结果表明,可以从差示扫描量热法热峰超调的幅度(即高度)获得β的一阶近似值。我们还发现,使用修正的VTF方程评估玻璃化转变时结构弛豫时间的温度依赖性,并将该表达式积分到更低温度,可以仅使用从单次差示扫描量热法扫描获得的ΔTg和β值,得到玻璃在任何温度下的弛豫时间常数τ(β)的评估值。这些估计的时间常数与用热活性监测仪直接测量的值非常吻合。