Boumans Nicolle P G, Landeweerd Jan A, Visser Mildred
Faculty of Health Sciences, Department of Health Organization, Policy and Economics, Maastricht University, Maastricht, The Netherlands.
Scand J Caring Sci. 2004 Mar;18(1):37-48. doi: 10.1111/j.1471-6712.2004.00253.x.
This article describes a quantitative study of the relationship between differentiated practice on the one side and patient-oriented care and quality of work on the other. Nursing wards where differentiated practice has been implemented (intervention group) have been compared with wards where differentiated practice has not been implemented (reference group). The research variables with regard to differentiated practice, patient-oriented care and quality of work have been measured by questionnaires. Subjects were 68 nurses and six supervisors from six nursing wards from one hospital. The results show that the extent to which differentiated practice had been implemented varied between the wards. With regard to patient-oriented care differences have been found between the intervention and reference group on the variables patient assignment and use of the nursing process, but not on the variables of tasks and communication. Concerning quality of work, differences have been found on: social support from the supervisor, social-emotional leadership and health complaints. Rank order correlations between differentiated practice and patient-oriented care and between differentiated practice and quality of work were not significant. Practical implications with regard to the use of differentiated practice and implications for further research are discussed.
本文描述了一项定量研究,该研究一方面探讨差异化实践与以患者为导向的护理及工作质量之间的关系。已实施差异化实践的护理病房(干预组)与未实施差异化实践的病房(参照组)进行了对比。关于差异化实践、以患者为导向的护理及工作质量的研究变量通过问卷调查进行测量。研究对象为来自一家医院六个护理病房的68名护士和六名主管。结果显示,各病房实施差异化实践的程度有所不同。在以患者为导向的护理方面,干预组和参照组在患者分配和护理流程使用变量上存在差异,但在任务和沟通变量上不存在差异。在工作质量方面,在主管的社会支持、社会情感领导能力和健康投诉方面发现了差异。差异化实践与以患者为导向的护理之间以及差异化实践与工作质量之间的等级相关均不显著。文中讨论了差异化实践使用方面的实际意义以及对进一步研究的启示。