Oztas Murat Orhan, Calikoglu Emel, Baz Kiymet, Birol Ahu, Onder Meltem, Calikoglu Tamer, Kitapci Mehmet T
Department of Dermatology, Gazi University, Turkey.
J Telemed Telecare. 2004;10(1):25-8. doi: 10.1258/135763304322764158.
We studied the reliability of teledermatology diagnoses made using a Web-based system. Clinical photographs and information relating to 125 patients were placed on a Web server. Three dermatologists made the most likely diagnosis via a Web interface. The reference diagnosis was made in a face-to-face consultation with a fourth dermatologist; where appropriate it was confirmed histologically. The teledermatologists were correct in 57% of cases when viewing the images alone. Their diagnostic accuracy improved to 70% when additional clinical information was available. The rate of agreement between the teledermatologists ranged from 44% to 70% (kappa= 0.22-0.32). Seventy-seven per cent of the patients were correctly diagnosed by at least two dermatologists when clinical information was provided. A Web-based system appears to be reliable for teledermatology. A single well trained teledermatologist may give better results than a group of less well trained clinicians.
我们研究了使用基于网络的系统进行远程皮肤病学诊断的可靠性。125名患者的临床照片及相关信息被放置在网络服务器上。三位皮肤科医生通过网络界面做出最有可能的诊断。参考诊断由第四位皮肤科医生进行面对面会诊做出;在适当情况下通过组织学确诊。仅查看图像时,远程皮肤科医生在57%的病例中诊断正确。当有额外临床信息时,他们的诊断准确率提高到70%。远程皮肤科医生之间的一致率在44%至70%之间(kappa = 0.22 - 0.32)。提供临床信息时,77%的患者被至少两位皮肤科医生正确诊断。基于网络的系统似乎对远程皮肤病学是可靠的。一名训练有素的远程皮肤科医生可能比一组训练欠佳的临床医生给出更好的结果。