Weintraub Michael I, Cole Steven P
New York Medical College, Briarcliff Manor, New York 10510, USA.
Neurorehabil Neural Repair. 2004 Mar;18(1):42-6. doi: 10.1177/0888439003261024.
CONTEXT: Neuropathic pain (NP) from peripheral neuropathy (PN) arises from ectopic firing of unmyelinated C-fibers with accumulation of sodium and calcium channels. Because pulsed electromagnetic fields (PEMF) safely induce extremely low frequency (ELF) quasirectangular currents that can depolarize, repolarize, and hyperpolarize neurons, it was hypothesized that directing this energy into the sole of one foot could potentially modulate neuropathic pain. OBJECTIVE: To determine if 9 consecutive 1-h treatments in physician's office (excluding weekends) of a pulsed signal therapy can reduce NP scores in refractory feet with PN. DESIGN/SETTING/PATIENTS: 24 consecutive patients with refractory and symptomatic PN from diabetes, chronic inflammatory demyelinating polyneuropathy (CIDP), pernicious anemia, mercury poisoning, paraneoplastic syndrome, tarsal tunnel, and idiopathic sensory neuropathy were enrolled in this nonplacebo pilot study. The most symptomatic foot received therapy. Primary endpoints were comparison of VAS scores at the end of 9 days and the end of 30 days follow-up compared to baseline pain scores. Additionally, Patients' Global Impression of Change (PGIC) questionnaire was tabulated describing response to treatment. Subgroup analysis of nerve conduction scores, quantified sensory testing (QST), and serial examination changes were also tabulated. Subgroup classification of pain (Serlin) was utilized to determine if there were disproportionate responses. INTERVENTION: Noninvasive pulsed signal therapy generates a unidirectional quasirectangular waveform with strength about 20 gauss and a frequency about 30 Hz into the soles of the feet for 9 consecutive 1-h treatments (excluding weekends). The most symptomatic foot of each patient was treated. RESULTS: All 24 feet completed 9 days of treatment. 15/24 completed follow-up (62%) with mean pain scores decreasing 21% from baseline to end of treatment (P=0.19) but with 49% reduction of pain scores from baseline to end of follow-up (P<0.01). Of this group, self-reported PGIC was improved 67% (n=10) and no change was 33% (n=5). An intent-to-treat analysis based on all 24 feet demonstrated a 19% reduction in pain scores from baseline to end of treatment (P=0.10) and a 37% decrease from baseline to end of follow-up (P<0.01). Subgroup analysis revealed 5 patients with mild pain with nonsignificant reduction at end of follow-up. Of the 19 feet with moderate to severe pain, there was a 28% reduction from baseline to end of treatment (P<0.05) and a 39% decrease from baseline to end of follow-up (P<0.01). Benefit was better in those patients with axonal changes and advanced CPT baseline scores. The clinical examination did not change. There were no adverse events or safety issues. CONCLUSIONS: These pilot data demonstrate that directing PEMF to refractory feet can provide unexpected shortterm analgesic effects in more than 50% of individuals. The role of placebo is not known and was not tested. The precise mechanism is unclear yet suggests that severe and advanced cases are more magnetically sensitive. Future studies are needed with randomized placebo-controlled design and longer treatment periods.
背景:周围神经病变(PN)引起的神经性疼痛(NP)源于无髓鞘C纤维的异位放电以及钠通道和钙通道的蓄积。由于脉冲电磁场(PEMF)能安全地诱发极低频(ELF)准矩形电流,该电流可使神经元去极化、复极化和超极化,因此推测将这种能量导入单足脚底可能会调节神经性疼痛。 目的:确定在医生办公室连续9次进行1小时的脉冲信号治疗(不包括周末)是否能降低患有PN的难治性足部的NP评分。 设计/地点/患者:本非安慰剂试点研究纳入了24例连续的患者,他们患有由糖尿病、慢性炎症性脱髓鞘性多发性神经病(CIDP)、恶性贫血、汞中毒、副肿瘤综合征、跗管综合征和特发性感觉神经病引起的难治性和有症状的PN。对症状最明显的足部进行治疗。主要终点是比较9天结束时和30天随访结束时的视觉模拟评分(VAS)与基线疼痛评分。此外,还汇总了患者总体变化印象(PGIC)问卷,以描述对治疗的反应。还汇总了神经传导评分、定量感觉测试(QST)和系列检查变化的亚组分析。采用疼痛亚组分类(塞尔林分类法)来确定是否存在不均衡反应。 干预:无创脉冲信号治疗在患者脚底产生一个强度约为20高斯、频率约为30赫兹的单向准矩形波形,连续进行9次1小时的治疗(不包括周末)。对每位患者症状最明显的足部进行治疗。 结果:所有24只脚均完成了9天的治疗。15只脚(62%)完成了随访,从基线到治疗结束时平均疼痛评分下降了21%(P = 0.19),但从基线到随访结束时疼痛评分降低了49%(P < 0.01)。在该组中,自我报告的PGIC改善了67%(n = 10),无变化为33%(n = )。基于所有24只脚的意向性分析表明,从基线到治疗结束时疼痛评分降低了19%(P = 0.10),从基线到随访结束时降低了37%(P < 0.01)。亚组分析显示,5例轻度疼痛患者在随访结束时疼痛减轻不显著。在19例中度至重度疼痛的足部中,从基线到治疗结束时疼痛降低了28%(P < 0.05),从基线到随访结束时降低了39%(P < 0.01)。轴突改变和冷觉定量试验(CPT)基线评分较高的患者获益更大。临床检查无变化。未出现不良事件或安全问题。 结论:这些试点数据表明,将PEMF作用于难治性足部可使超过50%的个体获得意外的短期镇痛效果。安慰剂的作用尚不清楚且未进行测试。确切机制尚不清楚,但表明严重和晚期病例对磁场更敏感。未来需要进行随机安慰剂对照设计和更长治疗期的研究。
Animals (Basel). 2024-3-13
Curr Diabetes Rev. 2024
Pharmaceutics. 2023-4-6
Wien Med Wochenschr. 2007-1