Cengiz Salih, Cengiz Karaca Ali, Cakir Ismail, Bülent Uner H, Sevindik Aytekin
Institute of Legal Medicine and Forensic Sciences, Istanbul University, Istanbul, Turkey.
Forensic Sci Int. 2004 Apr 20;141(1):33-7. doi: 10.1016/j.forsciint.2003.12.006.
Soils vary among different areas, and have some characteristics because of the natural effects and transfers made by human and other living beings in time. So that forensic examination of soil is not only concerned with the analysis of naturally occurring rocks, minerals, vegetation, and animal matter. It also includes the detection of such manufactured materials such as ions from synthetic fertilizers and from different environments (e.g., nitrate, phosphate, and sulfate) as environmental artifacts (e.g., lead or objects as glass, paint chips, asphalt, brick fragments, and cinders) whose presence may impart soil with characteristics that will make it unique to a particular location. Many screening and analytical methods have been applied for determining the characteristics which differentiate and discriminate the forensic soil samples but none of them easily standardized. Some of the methods that applied in forensic laboratories in forensic soil discrimination are the color comparison of the normal air-dried (dehumidified) and overheated soil samples, macroscopic observation, and low-power stereo-microscopic observation, determination of anionic composition by capillary electrophoresis (CE), and the elemental composition by scanning electron microscope (SEM)-energy dispersive X-ray spectrometer (EDS) and other high sensitivity techniques. The objective of this study was to show the effect of the application of 9 tonnes/cm2 pressure on the elemental compositions obtained by SEM-EDS technique and comparing the discrimination power of the pressed-homogenized and not homogenized forensic soil samples. For this purpose soil samples from 17 different locations of Istanbul were collected. Aliquots of the well mixed samples were dried in an oven at 110-120 degrees C and sieved by using 0.5 mm sieve and then the undersieve fraction(<0.5 mm) of these samples put on an adhesive tape placed on a stub. About 100-150 mg aliquots of dried, sieved samples were pressed under 9 tonnes/cm2 pressure by KBr disk preparation apparatus of an infrared spectrophotometer. Surfaces of the randomized particles and the pressed disks of the soil samples were scanned and the elemental compositions were determined with scanning electron microscope JEO-JSM-5600 equipped with an energy dispersive X-ray spectrometer OXFORD Link-ISIS-300. The samples from top of the sieves were examined with stereo-microscope equipped with JVC-TK-128DE color video camera and JVC-GV-PT2, digital video printer. Natural and artificial materials that have characteristic features were identified. Then for additional confirmation all soil samples were dried at 120 degrees C and over 780 degrees C and their colors compared. We concluded that pressing the whole sieved soil samples under 9 tonnes/cm2 pressure results in smashing over the harder particles into the softer matrix and results in homogenization of the soil sample. The elemental compositions of these samples obtained by SEM-EDS with 10-fold less standard deviation (S.D.) values and so that with more reproducibility and discrimination power.
不同地区的土壤各不相同,由于自然作用以及人类和其他生物长期的影响而具有一些特性。因此,土壤的法医检验不仅涉及对天然存在的岩石、矿物、植被和动物物质的分析。它还包括检测来自合成肥料和不同环境(如硝酸盐、磷酸盐和硫酸盐)的离子等人造物质,以及环境产物(如铅或玻璃、油漆碎片、沥青、砖碎片和煤渣等物体),这些物质的存在可能赋予土壤独特的特性,使其在特定地点独一无二。许多筛选和分析方法已被用于确定区分和鉴别法医土壤样本的特性,但没有一种方法易于标准化。法医实验室在法医土壤鉴别中应用的一些方法包括正常风干(除湿)和过热土壤样本的颜色比较、宏观观察和低倍立体显微镜观察、毛细管电泳(CE)测定阴离子组成,以及扫描电子显微镜(SEM)-能量色散X射线光谱仪(EDS)和其他高灵敏度技术测定元素组成。本研究的目的是展示施加9吨/平方厘米压力对通过SEM-EDS技术获得的元素组成的影响,并比较压制均质化和未均质化法医土壤样本的鉴别能力。为此,收集了伊斯坦布尔17个不同地点的土壤样本。将充分混合的样本等分在110-120摄氏度的烤箱中干燥,并用0.5毫米筛网筛分,然后将这些样本的筛下部分(<0.5毫米)放在置于短柱上的胶带上。约100-150毫克干燥、筛分后的样本通过红外分光光度计的KBr压片制备装置在9吨/平方厘米的压力下压制。对土壤样本随机颗粒表面和压制圆盘进行扫描,并用配备能量色散X射线光谱仪牛津Link-ISIS-300的扫描电子显微镜JEO-JSM-5600测定元素组成。用配备JVC-TK-128DE彩色摄像机和JVC-GV-PT2数字视频打印机的立体显微镜检查筛网上部的样本。识别具有特征的天然和人造物质。然后为了进一步确认,将所有土壤样本在120摄氏度和780摄氏度以上干燥,并比较它们的颜色。我们得出结论,在9吨/平方厘米的压力下压制整个筛分后的土壤样本会导致较硬颗粒破碎进入较软基质,从而使土壤样本均质化。通过SEM-EDS获得的这些样本的元素组成的标准偏差(S.D.)值降低了10倍,因此具有更高的重现性和鉴别能力。