Bol Roland, Moering Judith, Preedy Neil, Glaser Bruno
Institute of Grassland and Environmental Research, North Wyke Research Station, Okehampton, Devon, EX20 2SB, UK.
Isotopes Environ Health Stud. 2004 Mar;40(1):81-7. doi: 10.1080/10256010310001605955.
Surface application of animal wastes in intensive grassland systems has caused growing environmental problems during the last decade and, therefore, increasing public and scientific concern. In the present study we examined if the natural abundance 13C stable isotope tracer techniques could be used to investigate a poorly defined aspect of waste application, i.e. incorporation of slurry-derived C and its distribution in soil organic matter (SOM) fractions with different turnover times of a pasture soil. C3 and C4 slurries (delta13C(V-PDB) = -30.7/1000 and -21.3/1000, respectively) from cows fed either on a maize (C4) or perennial ryegrass (C3) diet were applied to a C3 soil with a delta13C value of (-30.0+/-0.2)/1000. The cattle slurry was applied at 50 m3 ha(-1). Coarse sand, fine sand, silt, clay and fine clay were isolated from bulk soil samples (0-2 cm depth), freeze-dried and ground prior to total organic C (TOC) using elemental analysis and 13C natural abundance analysis by isotope-ratio mass spectrometry. The stable isotope tracer technique did allow to quantify the short-term sequestration of slurry-derived C in particle-size fractions of the grassland soil. Slurry-derived carbon was sequestered in various amounts in the five particle-size fractions, but most of it was sequestered in the coarse sand fraction during the two week experiment. The preferential input into the coarse sand fraction suggests that only the larger particulate slurry-derived materials were trapped into the soil during the experimental period. Less than 40% of the applied slurry-derived C was sequestered into the soil, suggesting a potential for large losses into the wider environment. The practice of surface spreading of slurry to temperate grassland soils is clearly not efficient, and improvements in slurry application methods, such as incorporation directly into the soil, should therefore be encouraged.
在过去十年中,集约化草地系统中动物粪便的地表施用引发了越来越多的环境问题,因此也引起了公众和科学界越来越多的关注。在本研究中,我们探讨了是否可以使用天然丰度13C稳定同位素示踪技术来研究粪便施用中一个定义不明确的方面,即来自粪肥的碳的掺入及其在具有不同周转时间的牧场土壤有机物质(SOM)组分中的分布。分别以玉米(C4)或多年生黑麦草(C3)为食的奶牛产生的C3和C4粪肥(δ13C(V-PDB)分别为-30.7‰和-21.3‰)被施用于δ13C值为(-30.0±0.2)‰的C3土壤中。牛粪肥的施用量为50立方米/公顷。从表层土壤样品(0-2厘米深度)中分离出粗砂、细砂、粉砂、黏土和细黏土,冷冻干燥并研磨,然后使用元素分析测定总有机碳(TOC),并通过同位素比率质谱法进行13C天然丰度分析。稳定同位素示踪技术确实能够量化草地土壤颗粒级分中来自粪肥的碳的短期固存。在两周的实验期间,来自粪肥的碳以不同数量固存在五个颗粒级分中,但大部分固存在粗砂级分中。优先进入粗砂级分表明,在实验期间只有较大的颗粒状粪肥衍生物质被截留在土壤中。施用的粪肥衍生碳中不到40%被固存到土壤中,这表明可能有大量碳损失到更广泛的环境中。将粪肥地表撒施到温带草地土壤的做法显然效率不高,因此应该鼓励改进粪肥施用方法,例如直接将其掺入土壤中。