Cole Karan A, Barker L Randol, Kolodner Ken, Williamson Penelope, Wright Scott M, Kern David E
Johns Hopkins Faculty Development Program in Teaching Skills, and Division of General Internal Medicine, Johns Hopkins University, School of Medicine, Bayview Medical Center, Baltimore, MD 21224, USA.
Acad Med. 2004 May;79(5):469-80. doi: 10.1097/00001888-200405000-00019.
Although reflection contributes to the personal growth of clinician-educators and is important for effective teaching, few teaching skills programs report its use. The Johns Hopkins Faculty Development Program in Teaching Skills, first implemented in 1987 as a theoretically grounded, longitudinal model for faculty development of clinician-educators, comprises a set of conditions intended to promote reflective learning. This paper describes the program and reports evaluation results for 98 participants and a comparison group of 112 nonparticipants between 1988 and 1996. Participants met with facilitators weekly for nine months for 3.5 hours, in stable groups of four to six individuals. Educational methods used across seven content areas emphasized relationships and collaboration, and included information provision, experiential learning with reflection, and personal awareness sessions. A pre-post evaluation design with comparison group measured changes in self-assessed teaching and professional skills, teaching enjoyment, and learning effectiveness. A post-only evaluation design appraised overall program quality, educational methods, facilitation, learning environment, and perceived impact of participation. Program participants had significantly greater pre-post-change scores than nonparticipants for all 14 outcomes (p <.05). Multiple regression modeling indicated that program participation was associated with pre-post improvement in all outcomes except administration skills, controlling for all participant and nonparticipant baseline characteristics (p <.05). All measured programmatic characteristics were highly rated by participants. Experiential methods with reflection were rated significantly higher than information-provision and personal awareness sessions (p <.001). Evaluation results demonstrate a positive impact of this alternative approach to faculty development on clinician-educator perceptions of their attitudes and behaviors towards learners and colleagues.
尽管反思有助于临床教师教育者的个人成长,且对有效教学很重要,但很少有教学技能项目报告其使用情况。约翰·霍普金斯教学技能教师发展项目于1987年首次实施,是一个基于理论的临床教师教育者长期教师发展模式,包括一系列旨在促进反思性学习的条件。本文描述了该项目,并报告了1988年至1996年间98名参与者和112名非参与者对照组的评估结果。参与者每周与辅导员会面3.5小时,为期九个月,每组四至六人,保持稳定。七个内容领域使用的教育方法强调关系和协作,包括信息提供、带反思的体验式学习和个人意识课程。采用有对照组的前后评估设计来衡量自我评估的教学和专业技能、教学乐趣和学习效果的变化。仅采用后测评估设计来评估整体项目质量、教育方法、辅导、学习环境以及参与的感知影响。在所有14项结果中,项目参与者的前后变化得分显著高于非参与者(p <.05)。多元回归模型表明,在控制所有参与者和非参与者基线特征后,除管理技能外,项目参与与所有结果的前后改善相关(p <.05)。参与者对所有测量的项目特征评价都很高。带反思的体验式方法的评分显著高于信息提供和个人意识课程(p <.001)。评估结果表明,这种替代的教师发展方法对临床教师教育者对学习者和同事的态度及行为的认知产生了积极影响。