McDaniel Katherine L, Moser Virginia C
Neurotoxicology Division (Mail Code B105-04), National Health and Environmental Effects Research Laboratory, Office of Research and Development, U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Research Triangle Park, NC 27711, USA.
Neurotoxicol Teratol. 2004 May-Jun;26(3):407-15. doi: 10.1016/j.ntt.2004.01.001.
The relationship between cholinesterase (ChE) inhibition and neurobehavioral changes was examined using two ChE-inhibiting organophosphorus (OP) pesticides, fenamiphos and profenofos. Both pesticides produce considerable blood ChE inhibition, but relatively little brain inhibition up to almost lethal doses. Interestingly, pronounced neurobehavioral signs were produced by fenamiphos but not profenofos. After a single oral dose, both pesticides greatly inhibited blood ChE (87-98% inhibition), yet whole brain ChE was only inhibited by 9-14% at the highest doses. Fenamiphos produced dose-dependent effects on many behavioral measures. Despite the similar ChE inhibition profile, profenofos produced no observable changes in behavior. Treatment with anticholinergic drugs was used to evaluate the contribution of peripheral versus central ChE inhibition. Scopolamine (SCO) and methylscopolamine (MSC) were used as central/peripheral and peripheral-only cholinergic receptor blockers, respectively, in combination with fenamiphos. Neither drug altered the effects of fenamiphos on ChE inhibition. Some behavioral effects of fenamiphos were blocked or attenuated only by SCO, whereas other effects were blocked by both drugs. These data indicate that some of the pronounced neurobehavioral changes observed following fenamiphos dosing may be centrally mediated (blocked by SCO only), despite the small amount of inhibition of brain ChE. Other behavioral changes may be mediated more peripherally (blocked by both MSC and SCO). To test the hypothesis that regionally specific ChE inhibition may be responsible for these effects, the same dose of fenamiphos used in the previous studies was given and one half of the brain was dissected into regions. There was significant ChE inhibition in the pons and medulla, cerebellum, striatum, hippocampus, and half-brain but not in the rest-of-brain and frontal cortex; however, the magnitude of inhibition was relatively small across the regions measured. Thus, the centrally mediated neurobehavioral effects of fenamiphos could not be explained based on differential regional brain ChE inhibition alone. Despite the low level of brain ChE inhibition, some behavioral effects of fenamiphos were centrally mediated, and there was little regional specificity of ChE inhibition that could account for the behavioral changes observed.
使用两种抑制胆碱酯酶(ChE)的有机磷(OP)农药——苯线磷和丙溴磷,研究了ChE抑制与神经行为变化之间的关系。两种农药均可导致血液ChE显著抑制,但在接近致死剂量时,对脑ChE的抑制相对较小。有趣的是,苯线磷会产生明显的神经行为体征,而丙溴磷则不会。单次口服给药后,两种农药均能显著抑制血液ChE(抑制率为87 - 98%),但在最高剂量时,全脑ChE仅被抑制9 - 14%。苯线磷对多种行为指标产生剂量依赖性影响。尽管ChE抑制情况相似,但丙溴磷未引起可观察到的行为变化。使用抗胆碱能药物治疗来评估外周ChE抑制与中枢ChE抑制的作用。东莨菪碱(SCO)和甲基东莨菪碱(MSC)分别作为中枢/外周和仅外周胆碱能受体阻滞剂,与苯线磷联合使用。两种药物均未改变苯线磷对ChE的抑制作用。苯线磷的一些行为效应仅被SCO阻断或减弱,而其他效应则被两种药物均阻断。这些数据表明,尽管脑ChE抑制程度较小,但苯线磷给药后观察到的一些明显神经行为变化可能是由中枢介导的(仅被SCO阻断)。其他行为变化可能更多地由外周介导(被MSC和SCO均阻断)。为了验证区域特异性ChE抑制可能是这些效应的原因这一假设,给予与先前研究相同剂量的苯线磷,并将一半大脑解剖成不同区域。脑桥和延髓、小脑、纹状体、海马体及半脑均有显著的ChE抑制,但其余脑区和额叶皮质未出现;然而,在所测量的区域中,抑制程度相对较小。因此,仅基于不同区域脑ChE抑制无法解释苯线磷的中枢介导神经行为效应。尽管脑ChE抑制水平较低,但苯线磷的一些行为效应是由中枢介导的,且几乎没有ChE抑制的区域特异性能够解释所观察到的行为变化。