Eisenberg Mark J, Schechter David, Lefkovits Jeffrey, Goudreau Evelyne, Deligonul Ubeydullah, Mak Koon-Hou, Duerr Robert, Del Core Michael, Garzon Philippe, Huynh Thao, Smilovitch Mark, Sedlis Steven, Brown David L, Brieger David, Pilote Louise
Division of Cardiology, Jewish General Hospital/McGill University, Montreal, Quebec, Canada.
J Invasive Cardiol. 2004 Jun;16(6):318-22.
There is little consensus regarding the use of functional testing after percutaneous transluminal coronary angioplasty (PTCA). Some physicians employ a routine functional testing strategy, and others employ a symptom-driven strategy.
To examine the effects of routine post-PTCA functional testing on the use of follow-up cardiac procedures and clinical events.
The Routine versus Selective Exercise Treadmill Testing after Angioplasty (ROSETTA) Registry is a prospective multicenter observational study examining the use of functional testing after PTCA. A total of 788 patients (pts) were enrolled in the ROSETTA Registry at 13 clinical centers in 5 countries. The frequencies of functional testing, cardiac procedures and clinical events were examined during the first 6 months following a successful PTCA.
Patients were predominantly elderly men (mean age, 61+/-11 years; 76% male) who underwent single-vessel PTCA (85%) with stent implantation (58%). During the 6-month follow-up, a total of 237 pts were observed to undergo a routine functional testing strategy (100% having functional testing for routine follow-up), while 551 pts underwent a selective (or clinically-driven) strategy (73% having no functional testing and 27% having functional testing for a clinical indication). Patients in the routine testing group underwent a total of 344 functional tests compared with 165 tests performed in the selective testing group (mean, 1.45 tests/patient versus 0.3 tests/patient; p<0.0001). There was little difference in the rates of follow-up cardiac procedures among the pts undergoing the routine and selective testing strategies [cardiac catheterization, 13.9% versus 17.5% (p=NS); percutaneous coronary intervention (PCI), 8.4% versus 8.7% (p=NS); coronary artery bypass graft surgery, 2.1% versus 3.3% (p=NS)]. However, clinical events were less common among pts who underwent routine functional testing, e.g., unstable angina (6.1% versus 14.4%; p=0.001), myocardial infarction (0.4% versus 1.6%; p=NS), death (0% versus 2.2%; p=0.02) and composite clinical events (6.3% versus 16.3%; p<0.0001). After controlling for baseline clinical and procedural differences, routine functional testing had a persistent independent association with a reduction in the composite clinical event rate (odds ratio, 0.45; 95% confidence interval, 0.24-0.81; p=0.008).
Routine functional testing after PTCA is associated with a reduction in the frequency of follow-up clinical events. This association may be attributable to the early identification and treatment of pts at risk for follow-up events, or it may be due to clinical differences between pts who are referred for routine and selective functional testing.
经皮腔内冠状动脉成形术(PTCA)后功能测试的应用几乎没有达成共识。一些医生采用常规功能测试策略,另一些医生采用症状驱动策略。
研究PTCA术后常规功能测试对后续心脏手术使用情况和临床事件的影响。
血管成形术后常规与选择性运动平板试验(ROSETTA)注册研究是一项前瞻性多中心观察性研究,旨在研究PTCA后功能测试的应用。5个国家的13个临床中心共有788例患者纳入ROSETTA注册研究。在成功进行PTCA后的前6个月内,检查功能测试、心脏手术和临床事件的发生频率。
患者主要为老年男性(平均年龄61±11岁;76%为男性),接受单支血管PTCA(85%)并植入支架(58%)。在6个月的随访期间,共观察到237例患者采用常规功能测试策略(100%进行常规随访功能测试),而551例患者采用选择性(或临床驱动)策略(73%未进行功能测试,27%因临床指征进行功能测试)。常规测试组患者共进行了344次功能测试,而选择性测试组进行了165次测试(平均,1.45次/患者对0.3次/患者;p<0.0001)。采用常规和选择性测试策略的患者在后续心脏手术发生率方面差异不大[心脏导管检查,13.9%对17.5%(p=无显著性差异);经皮冠状动脉介入治疗(PCI),8.4%对8.7%(p=无显著性差异);冠状动脉旁路移植手术,2.1%对3.3%(p=无显著性差异)]。然而,在接受常规功能测试的患者中临床事件较少见例如,不稳定型心绞痛(6.1%对14.4%;p=0.001)、心肌梗死(0.4%对1.6%;p=无显著性差异)、死亡(0%对2.2%;p=0.02)和复合临床事件(6.3%对16.3%;p<0.0001)。在控制基线临床和手术差异后,常规功能测试与复合临床事件发生率降低持续独立相关(优势比,0.45;95%置信区间,0.24 - 0.81;p=0.008)。
PTCA术后常规功能测试与随访临床事件频率降低相关。这种关联可能归因于对有随访事件风险患者的早期识别和治疗,或者可能是由于接受常规和选择性功能测试患者之间的临床差异。