Baker G Ross, Norton Peter G, Flintoft Virginia, Blais Régis, Brown Adalsteinn, Cox Jafna, Etchells Ed, Ghali William A, Hébert Philip, Majumdar Sumit R, O'Beirne Maeve, Palacios-Derflingher Luz, Reid Robert J, Sheps Sam, Tamblyn Robyn
Department of Health Policy, Management and Evaluation, University of Toronto, McMurrich Building Room 2031, 12 Queen's Park Crescent West, Toronto, Ontario M5S 1A8, Canada.
CMAJ. 2004 May 25;170(11):1678-86. doi: 10.1503/cmaj.1040498.
Research into adverse events (AEs) has highlighted the need to improve patient safety. AEs are unintended injuries or complications resulting in death, disability or prolonged hospital stay that arise from health care management. We estimated the incidence of AEs among patients in Canadian acute care hospitals.
We randomly selected 1 teaching, 1 large community and 2 small community hospitals in each of 5 provinces (British Columbia, Alberta, Ontario, Quebec and Nova Scotia) and reviewed a random sample of charts for nonpsychiatric, nonobstetric adult patients in each hospital for the fiscal year 2000. Trained reviewers screened all eligible charts, and physicians reviewed the positively screened charts to identify AEs and determine their preventability.
At least 1 screening criterion was identified in 1527 (40.8%) of 3745 charts. The physician reviewers identified AEs in 255 of the charts. After adjustment for the sampling strategy, the AE rate was 7.5 per 100 hospital admissions (95% confidence interval [CI] 5.7- 9.3). Among the patients with AEs, events judged to be preventable occurred in 36.9% (95% CI 32.0%-41.8%) and death in 20.8% (95% CI 7.8%-33.8%). Physician reviewers estimated that 1521 additional hospital days were associated with AEs. Although men and women experienced equal rates of AEs, patients who had AEs were significantly older than those who did not (mean age [and standard deviation] 64.9 [16.7] v. 62.0 [18.4] years; p = 0.016).
The overall incidence rate of AEs of 7.5% in our study suggests that, of the almost 2.5 million annual hospital admissions in Canada similar to the type studied, about 185 000 are associated with an AE and close to 70 000 of these are potentially preventable.
对不良事件(AE)的研究凸显了提高患者安全的必要性。不良事件是指因医疗保健管理而导致的意外损伤或并发症,可造成死亡、残疾或延长住院时间。我们估算了加拿大急症护理医院患者中不良事件的发生率。
我们在5个省份(不列颠哥伦比亚省、艾伯塔省、安大略省、魁北克省和新斯科舍省)中,每个省份随机选取1所教学医院、1所大型社区医院和2所小型社区医院,并回顾了2000财年各医院非精神科、非产科成年患者的随机抽样病历。经过培训的审查人员筛查了所有符合条件的病历,医生审查了筛查呈阳性的病历,以确定不良事件并判断其可预防性。
在3745份病历中,有1527份(40.8%)至少符合1条筛查标准。医生审查人员在其中255份病历中发现了不良事件。在对抽样策略进行调整后,不良事件发生率为每100例住院患者中有7.5例(95%置信区间[CI] 5.7 - 9.3)。在发生不良事件的患者中,被判定为可预防的事件占36.9%(95% CI 32.0% - 41.8%),死亡事件占20.8%(95% CI 7.8% - 33.8%)。医生审查人员估计,不良事件还导致额外1521个住院日。虽然男性和女性发生不良事件的比率相同,但发生不良事件的患者明显比未发生不良事件的患者年龄更大(平均年龄[及标准差] 64.9 [16.7]岁对62.0 [18.4]岁;p = 0.016)。
我们研究中不良事件的总体发生率为7.5%,这表明在加拿大每年近250万例与本研究类型相似的住院病例中,约18.5万例与不良事件相关,其中近7万例可能是可预防的。