Lee Patrick Y, Bazar Kimberly A, Yun A Joon
Department of Radiology, Stanford University, 470 University Avenue, Palo Alto, CA 94301, USA.
Med Hypotheses. 2004;63(1):163-7. doi: 10.1016/j.mehy.2004.02.036.
Exacerbation of certain medical conditions during specific phases of the menstrual cycle has long been recognized. Mechanisms of the cyclic variations are poorly understood, but are often attributed to fluctuations in reproductive hormones. We hypothesize that normal variations in autonomic balance during the menstrual cycle, which likely evolved as adaptations for reproduction, may contribute to catamenial variations in diseases independent of hormonal variations. Emerging evidence suggests that autonomic balance shifts towards sympathetic bias during the second half of the menstrual cycle. This shift can be seen as an evolutionary adaptation to address the immunologic and physiologic demands for successful implantation and gestation. Through direct modulation of lymphoid system and activation of the cortisol pathway, sympathetic bias promotes a shift to relative T helper (Th)-2-biased immunity which may favor maternal tolerance of the embryo by attenuating Th-1-mediated interference of implantation. Immune variance during the menstrual cycle has been implicated in menstrual fluctuations of many diseases, but until now the immune variance has been attributed to female hormonal changes. We propose that shifts in autonomic balance independently contribute to fluctuations in diseases by modulating the immune system. Still further, we propose that many other diseases fluctuate due to the direct nervous system actions of shifts in autonomic balance. Our hypothesis portends new therapeutic paradigms based on cyclical modulation of autonomic balance to address catamenial variations of medical conditions.
某些疾病在月经周期特定阶段的加重早已为人所知。这种周期性变化的机制尚不清楚,但通常归因于生殖激素的波动。我们假设,月经周期中自主神经平衡的正常变化可能是为适应生殖而进化而来的,它可能导致疾病的月经周期变化,而与激素变化无关。新出现的证据表明,在月经周期的后半期,自主神经平衡向交感神经偏倚转变。这种转变可被视为一种进化适应,以满足成功着床和妊娠的免疫和生理需求。通过直接调节淋巴系统和激活皮质醇途径,交感神经偏倚促进向相对的辅助性T细胞(Th)-2偏向性免疫转变,这可能通过减弱Th-1介导的着床干扰而有利于母体对胚胎的耐受。月经周期中的免疫变化与许多疾病的月经波动有关,但到目前为止,免疫变化一直归因于女性激素变化。我们提出,自主神经平衡的转变通过调节免疫系统独立地导致疾病波动。更进一步,我们提出,许多其他疾病因自主神经平衡转变的直接神经系统作用而波动。我们的假设预示着基于自主神经平衡的周期性调节来解决疾病月经周期变化的新治疗模式。