Vaamonde J, Ibáñez R, García A M, Poblete V
Servicio de Neurología, Complejo Hospitalario de Ciudad Real, Ciudad Real.
Neurologia. 2004 Jul-Aug;19(6):292-300.
Essential tremor (ET) may be misdiagnosed as idiopathic Parkinson's disease (PD). In neurodegenerative diseases, structural imaging, such as CT or MRI, is of limited value for differentiating parkinsonian syndromes since structural changes are often only evident by the time the disease is far advanced. Most cases of symptomatic parkinsonism are vascular parkinsonism, but PD may coexist. The differential diagnosis between Alzheimer's disease (AD) and dementia with Lewy bodies (LBD) is often difficult.
To define the utility of functional neuroimaging test to establish differential diagnosis between PD and ET, drug induced parkinsonism, multiple system atrophy and vascular parkinsonism, and between AD and LBD, when clinical presentation, evolution or treatment response are atypical.
A group of 75 patients with parkinsonism was examined by clinical assessment and DaTSCAN (123I-FP-CTI, dopamine transporter protein marker) and/or IBZM SPECT (D2 receptor marker). The patients were recruited from our outpatient clinic.
Correlation between initial clinical diagnosis and functional imaging studies (DaTSCAN and/or IBZM SPECT) in our patients did not reach that described (more than 90 %) for these techniques in previously published studies. Conclusions. According to sensitivity and sensibility reported in previous imaging studies of the pre and/or postsynaptic dopaminergic system using DaTSCAN and/ or IBZM, SPECT may be a new tool in the diagnosis of parkinsonian patients with difficult clinical diagnosis.
特发性震颤(ET)可能被误诊为特发性帕金森病(PD)。在神经退行性疾病中,诸如CT或MRI等结构成像对于区分帕金森综合征的价值有限,因为结构变化通常在疾病进展到晚期时才明显。大多数症状性帕金森症病例是血管性帕金森症,但PD也可能与之共存。阿尔茨海默病(AD)和路易体痴呆(LBD)之间的鉴别诊断通常很困难。
当临床表现、病情演变或治疗反应不典型时,确定功能性神经成像检查在建立PD与ET、药物性帕金森症、多系统萎缩和血管性帕金森症之间,以及AD与LBD之间鉴别诊断中的作用。
一组75例帕金森症患者接受了临床评估以及DaTSCAN(123I-FP-CTI,多巴胺转运蛋白标记物)和/或IBZM SPECT(D2受体标记物)检查。这些患者是从我们的门诊招募的。
我们患者的初始临床诊断与功能性成像研究(DaTSCAN和/或IBZM SPECT)之间的相关性未达到先前发表研究中描述的这些技术的相关性(超过90%)。结论。根据先前使用DaTSCAN和/或IBZM对突触前和/或突触后多巴胺能系统进行成像研究报告的敏感性和特异性,SPECT可能是诊断临床诊断困难的帕金森病患者的一种新工具。