Hubacher Markus, Allenbach Roland
Swiss Council for Accident Prevention bfu, CP, CH-3001 Bern, Switzerland.
Accid Anal Prev. 2004 Sep;36(5):739-47. doi: 10.1016/j.aap.2003.05.004.
In this study it was endeavored to predict full green and green arrow accidents at traffic lights, using configuration-specific features. This was done using the statistical method known as Poisson regression. A total of 45 sets of traffic lights (criteria: in an urban area, with four approach roads) with 178 approach roads were investigated (the data from two approach roads was unable to be used). Configuration-specific features were surveyed on all approach roads (characteristics of traffic lanes, road signs, traffic lights, etc.), traffic monitored and accidents (full green and green arrow) recorded over a period of 5 consecutive years. It was demonstrated that only between 23 and 34% of variance could be explained with the models predicting both types of accidents. In green arrow accidents, the approach road topography was found to be the major contributory factor to an accident: if the approach road slopes downwards, the risk of a green arrow accident is approximately five and a half times greater (relative risk, RR = 5.56) than on a level or upward sloping approach road. With full green accidents, obstructed vision plays the major role: where vision can be obstructed by vehicles turning off, the accident risk is eight times greater (RR = 8.08) than where no comparable obstructed vision is possible. From the study it emerges that technical features of traffic lights are not able to control a driver's actions in such a way as to eradicate error. Other factors, in particular the personal characteristics of the driver (age, sex, etc.) and accident circumstances (lighting, road conditions, etc.), are likely to make an important contribution to explaining how an accident occurs.
在本研究中,我们尝试利用特定配置特征来预测交通信号灯处的全绿灯和绿灯箭头事故。这是通过一种名为泊松回归的统计方法来完成的。总共对45组交通信号灯(标准:位于市区,有四条引道)以及178条引道进行了调查(两条引道的数据无法使用)。对所有引道的特定配置特征进行了调查(行车道、道路标志、交通信号灯等的特征),并连续5年监测交通情况并记录事故(全绿灯和绿灯箭头事故)。结果表明,预测这两种类型事故的模型只能解释23%至34%的方差。在绿灯箭头事故中,引道地形被发现是事故的主要促成因素:如果引道向下倾斜,绿灯箭头事故的风险比水平或向上倾斜的引道大约高五点五倍(相对风险,RR = 5.56)。对于全绿灯事故,视线受阻起主要作用:在车辆转弯可能会阻挡视线的地方,事故风险比不存在类似视线受阻情况的地方高八倍(RR = 8.08)。从该研究可以看出,交通信号灯的技术特征无法以消除错误的方式控制驾驶员的行为。其他因素,特别是驾驶员的个人特征(年龄、性别等)和事故情况(照明、道路状况等),可能对解释事故发生的原因有重要贡献。