Kentridge R W, Heywood C A, Milner A D
Department of Psychology, Cognitive Neuroscience Research Unit, University of Durham, South Road, Durham DH1 3LE, UK.
Neuropsychologia. 2004;42(11):1488-95. doi: 10.1016/j.neuropsychologia.2004.03.007.
The patient D.F., who suffers from severe visual form agnosia, has been found to have a bilateral lesion of area LO, an area known to be intimately involved in the perception of object shape. Despite her perceptual impairment, however, D.F. retains residual form processing abilities that can provide distal visuomotor control, for example in the configuration of her grasp when reaching to pick up objects of different shapes and sizes. This dissociation has been interpreted as reflecting the sparing of a dedicated system for processing the physical properties of objects solely for purposes of guiding action. Here we test this hypothesis in two studies designed to examine whether or not spared shape processing capacities might be revealed under other kinds of indirect test conditions. First, we exploited the fact that a redundant shape cue will speed search for a coloured stimulus within an array, and vice versa. Unlike our control subjects, D.F. showed no facilitation effect of either kind. Second, we used two Stroop tasks in which single coloured uppercase letters were presented. Our intention was to determine (a) whether naming the colour would be influenced by whether the letter was the initial letter of the correct or incorrect colour name (e.g. 'R' or 'G'); and (b) whether the reverse might be true, that is that D.F.'s guesses at letter identity might be influenced by their colour. We found no evidence for a Stroop effect of the former (standard) kind in D.F., but we did find evidence for reverse-Stroop effects. This result may reflect a partial sparing of ventral stream areas specialised for letter-form processing.
患者D.F.患有严重的视觉形状失认症,研究发现其大脑枕叶外侧区(LO区)出现双侧损伤,该区域与物体形状感知密切相关。然而,尽管存在感知障碍,D.F.仍保留了残余的形状处理能力,这些能力可用于提供远距离视觉运动控制,例如在伸手去拿不同形状和大小的物体时调整抓握动作。这种分离现象被解释为反映了一个专门用于处理物体物理属性以指导行动的系统未受损伤。在此,我们通过两项研究来验证这一假设,旨在探究在其他类型的间接测试条件下,是否能揭示出未受损伤的形状处理能力。首先,我们利用了这样一个事实:冗余的形状线索会加快在一组刺激中搜索有色刺激的速度,反之亦然。与我们的对照组受试者不同,D.F.并未表现出任何一种促进效应。其次,我们使用了两项斯特鲁普任务,其中呈现单个大写彩色字母。我们的目的是确定:(a)说出颜色的过程是否会受到字母是正确或错误颜色名称首字母(例如“R”或“G”)的影响;(b)反之是否成立,即D.F.对字母身份的猜测是否会受到其颜色的影响。我们没有发现D.F.存在前一种(标准)类型的斯特鲁普效应的证据,但确实发现了反向斯特鲁普效应的证据。这一结果可能反映了专门用于字母形状处理的腹侧流区域部分未受损伤。