Kuo Anda K, Ma Christine T, Kamei Robert K
Department of Pediatrics, San Francisco General Hospital and University of California, 94110, USA.
Ambul Pediatr. 2004 Jul-Aug;4(4):332-5. doi: 10.1367/A03-167R.1.
Residency programs with postcall afternoon continuity clinics violate the new Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education (ACGME) limitations on resident duty hours. We evaluated housestaff experience with a pilot intervention that replaced postcall continuity clinics with evening continuity clinics.
We began this pilot program at one continuity clinic site for pediatric residents. Instead of postcall clinics, residents had evening continuity clinic added to a regular clinic day when they were neither postcall nor on call. At 5 and 11 months, we surveyed housestaff satisfaction and experience with the evening clinics, particularly in comparison to postcall clinics.
Nineteen of 23 pediatric residents participated in the pilot program. Twenty-two and 17 residents completed the 5- and 11-month follow-up surveys, respectively. A significantly greater proportion of residents rated their overall satisfaction with evening clinic as good/outstanding (16/18, 89%) compared with postcall clinic (2/19, 11%) at the 5-month survey (P<.01). Resident preference for evening clinic over postcall clinic persisted but was not statistically significant at 11 months (P =.05), and overall satisfaction with evening clinic was unchanged from the 5- and 11-month surveys (P =.64). All areas of patient care, medical education, and clinic infrastructure were better or equal in evening clinic in comparison to postcall clinic except for continuity of preceptors and access to medical services.
Housestaff had greater satisfaction and a better clinic experience with evening clinic versus postcall clinic. Evening continuity clinic is a viable solution to meeting the ACGME work hour limitations while preserving housestaff primary care education.
住院医师培训项目中,交班后下午的连续性门诊违反了研究生医学教育认证委员会(ACGME)对住院医师值班时长的新限制。我们评估了一项试点干预措施,该措施用夜间连续性门诊取代交班后连续性门诊,观察住院医师的体验。
我们在一个儿科住院医师连续性门诊地点启动了这个试点项目。住院医师在既不处于交班后也不处于值班状态的常规门诊日增加了夜间连续性门诊,而非交班后门诊。在5个月和11个月时,我们调查了住院医师对夜间门诊的满意度和体验,特别是与交班后门诊相比。
23名儿科住院医师中有19名参与了试点项目。分别有22名和17名住院医师完成了5个月和11个月的随访调查。在5个月的调查中,与交班后门诊(2/19,11%)相比,显著更多比例的住院医师将他们对夜间门诊的总体满意度评为良好/优秀(16/18,89%)(P<0.01)。住院医师对夜间门诊的偏好超过交班后门诊的情况持续存在,但在11个月时无统计学意义(P = 0.05),并且从5个月到11个月的调查中,对夜间门诊的总体满意度没有变化(P = 0.64)。与交班后门诊相比,除了带教老师的连续性和获得医疗服务的机会外,夜间门诊在患者护理、医学教育和门诊基础设施的所有方面都更好或相当。
与交班后门诊相比,住院医师对夜间门诊的满意度更高,门诊体验更好。夜间连续性门诊是在满足ACGME工作时长限制的同时,保留住院医师初级保健教育的可行解决方案。