Kavsak Peter A, Zielinski Nuala, Li Dailin, McNamara Patrick J, Adeli Khosrow
Division of Clinical Biochemistry, Hospital for Sick Children, University of Toronto, Toronto, ON, M5G 1X8, Canada.
Clin Biochem. 2004 Sep;37(9):811-7. doi: 10.1016/j.clinbiochem.2004.06.003.
To investigate factors contributing to analytical bias in POCT glucose values generated by the NICU versus the core laboratory.
The LifeScan Flexx hospital system glucose meters (SureStep) were used in precision and comparison studies between the NICU and laboratory (ABL715 and Vitros 950).
Analysis of 40 neonatal blood samples revealed a positive bias between the NICU glucose meters versus either the laboratory glucose meter or instrument (mean difference of 0.28 and 0.21 mmol/L, respectively). Linear regression analysis (R2 = 0.0584) of the difference in glucose results versus time elapsed between measurements indicated that the bias observed between the NICU and laboratory glucose meters was not due to in vitro glycolysis for samples transported on ice. Further analysis indicated that the bias appeared to be mostly operator driven, with different NICU operators exhibiting different mean biases. Increasing the amount of blood applied to the SureStep Pro test strip (e.g., 60 vs. 20 microL), led to higher values for glucose concentration for the same blood. Nearly 50% of all glucose values reported for the NICU were obtained by the SureStep Flexx glucose meters in a 3-month period following the introduction of POCT, yet the number of laboratory-reported glucose results for the same period increased by 21% as compared to the previous year.
Operator error appears to be a source of bias present between the NICU and laboratory, and despite glucose meter utilization in the NICU, the number of glucose measurements by the central laboratory increased after POCT introduction.
研究导致新生儿重症监护病房(NICU)与核心实验室所测即时检验(POCT)血糖值出现分析偏差的因素。
在NICU与实验室(ABL715和Vitros 950)之间的精密度和对比研究中使用了LifeScan Flexx医院系统血糖仪(SureStep)。
对40份新生儿血样的分析显示,NICU血糖仪与实验室血糖仪或仪器之间存在正偏差(平均差异分别为0.28和0.21 mmol/L)。血糖结果差异与测量间隔时间的线性回归分析(R2 = 0.0584)表明,NICU与实验室血糖仪之间观察到的偏差并非由冰上运输样本的体外糖酵解所致。进一步分析表明,这种偏差似乎主要由操作人员导致,不同的NICU操作人员表现出不同的平均偏差。增加SureStep Pro测试条上的血量(例如,60 μL对20 μL),会使同一血液的葡萄糖浓度值更高。在引入POCT后的3个月内,NICU报告的所有血糖值中近50%是通过SureStep Flexx血糖仪获得的,但与上一年相比,同期实验室报告的血糖结果数量增加了21%。
操作人员误差似乎是NICU与实验室之间存在偏差的一个来源,并且尽管NICU使用了血糖仪,但引入POCT后中央实验室的血糖测量数量增加了。