Hawton Keith, Harriss Louise, Simkin Sue, Bale Elizabeth, Bond Alison
Centre for Suicide Research, Department of Psychiatry, University of Oxford, Warneford Hospital, Headington, Oxford OX3 7JX, UK.
Suicide Life Threat Behav. 2004 Autumn;34(3):199-208. doi: 10.1521/suli.34.3.199.42776.
A large ( n = 14,892) consecutive sample of deliberate self-harm (attempted suicide) patients who presented to a general hospital in the United Kingdom during a 23-year study period was examined (over two consecutive time periods) in order to compare the characteristics of those who used self-cutting ( n = 428) and those who self-poisoned ( n = 11,065). Patients who used different methods on other occasions, or were not assessed by the psychiatric service, were excluded. In the first time period (January 1976-June 1988), the self-cutters were distinguished from the self-poisoners by more often being male, single, not employed, and having a history of previous deliberate self-harm. In the second time period (July 1988-December 1998) the self-cutters were again distinguished by more often being male and having a history of previous deliberate self-harm, but also by being more likely to live alone, misuse alcohol, and have low suicidal intent scores. The finding of an excess of males among the self-cutters is contrary to the impression in the literature that self-cutting presentations to general hospitals more often involve females. It also indicates that the treatment needs of those who deliberately cut themselves are likely to differ from those of self-poisoners.
在一项为期23年的研究期间,对英国一家综合医院收治的大量(n = 14,892)连续的蓄意自我伤害(自杀未遂)患者样本(分两个连续时间段)进行了检查,以比较使用自我切割方式的患者(n = 428)和使用自我中毒方式的患者(n = 11,065)的特征。排除了在其他场合使用不同方法或未接受精神科服务评估的患者。在第一个时间段(1976年1月至1988年6月),自我切割者与自我中毒者的区别在于,前者男性更多、单身、未就业且有过蓄意自我伤害史。在第二个时间段(1988年7月至1998年12月),自我切割者的特征同样是男性更多且有过蓄意自我伤害史,但还包括更有可能独居、滥用酒精且自杀意图得分较低。自我切割者中男性过多这一发现与文献中的印象相反,文献认为综合医院中自我切割案例更多涉及女性。这也表明蓄意自我切割者的治疗需求可能与自我中毒者不同。