Walter G
Northside Clinic, Sydney, Australia.
Acta Psychiatr Scand. 1992 Feb;85(2):167-72. doi: 10.1111/j.1600-0447.1992.tb01463.x.
The portrayal of psychiatrists in cartoons from the United States was examined. A total of 404 cartoons from 1941 to 1990 were obtained and arranged chronologically. The appearance, behaviour, treatment methods and efficacy of the cartoon psychiatrist were assessed. It was found that there has been little change in these parameters over the past 50 years. This finding is partly explained by the constraints of the cartoon medium and by the workings of humour and stereotyping. Psychiatric cartoons from other countries and those drawn by psychiatrists themselves do not depart from the American pattern. The differences between the representation of psychiatrists in the cartoon and in other media, such as the film, are highlighted. It is postulated that the cartoon serves to stabilize the more mutable portrayals of psychiatrists in other media. Further studies are suggested.
对美国卡通片中精神科医生的形象进行了研究。共获取了1941年至1990年的404幅卡通画,并按时间顺序排列。对卡通片中精神科医生的外貌、行为、治疗方法和疗效进行了评估。结果发现,在过去50年里这些参数几乎没有变化。这一发现部分可以通过卡通媒介的限制以及幽默和刻板印象的作用来解释。来自其他国家的精神科卡通画以及精神科医生自己绘制的卡通画也未偏离美国模式。文中强调了卡通片中精神科医生的形象与电影等其他媒介中形象的差异。据推测,卡通有助于稳定精神科医生在其他媒介中更易变的形象。建议进行进一步的研究。