Orstavik D, Mjör I A
NIOM-Scandinavian Institute of Dental Materials, Haslum, Norway.
Oral Surg Oral Med Oral Pathol. 1992 Mar;73(3):337-44. doi: 10.1016/0030-4220(92)90132-a.
Root canals with vital pulps in four Macaca fascicularis monkeys were subjected to pulp extirpation and root filling with gutta-percha and sealer, either AH26, Endomethasone, Kloroperka N-phi, or ProcoSol. Observation periods were 1 and 6 months. The results of treatment were evaluated by radiographic analysis (periapical index scores) and by histopathologic assessment of the remaining pulp and periapical tissues. Sixty roots with acceptable termination (between 0.5 and 3 mm from apex) of the root fillings and adequate histopathologic specimens were available for analysis. These roots were equally distributed in each observation period group and among the four material groups. Radiography indicated periapical pathosis in 6 of the 60 roots--4 at 1 month and 2 at 6 months. Periapical inflammation was observed on histopathologic examination in 17 roots--11 after 1 month and 6 after 6 months. Histologic and radiographic assessment of periapical inflammation was significantly correlated (p less than 0.01, chi 2) at the 6-month observation period. No granuloma or cyst formation was evident on histologic examination. The magnitude of the inflammatory response appeared unrelated to the endodontic sealer used, and several inflammatory foci were not related to foreign bodies in the tissues. Bacteriologic sampling showed growth in thioglycollate broth cultures in 9 of the 60 roots, but the presence of cultivable bacteria by this technique was unrelated to inflammatory changes. Histologic demonstration of bacteria was positive in 4 roots, all of which were associated with inflammatory periapical reactions. The method applied in the present study did not provide a sensitive discrimination among endodontic materials of widely different chemical composition.
对4只食蟹猴中牙髓活力正常的根管进行牙髓摘除术,并用牙胶和封闭剂(AH26、Endomethasone、Kloroperka N-phi或ProcoSol)进行根管充填。观察期为1个月和6个月。通过影像学分析(根尖指数评分)以及对剩余牙髓和根尖周组织的组织病理学评估来评价治疗结果。共有60个根管充填终止位置可接受(距根尖0.5至3毫米之间)且有足够组织病理学标本的根管可供分析。这些根管在每个观察期组和四个材料组中均匀分布。影像学检查显示,60个根管中有6个存在根尖周病变——1个月时4个,6个月时2个。组织病理学检查发现17个根管存在根尖周炎症——1个月后11个,6个月后6个。在6个月观察期时,根尖周炎症的组织学和影像学评估显著相关(p<0.01,卡方检验)。组织学检查未发现肉芽肿或囊肿形成。炎症反应的程度似乎与所使用的牙髓封闭剂无关,且一些炎症灶与组织中的异物无关。细菌学采样显示,60个根管中有9个在硫乙醇酸盐肉汤培养中有细菌生长,但通过该技术培养出的细菌与炎症变化无关。4个根管的细菌组织学显示为阳性,所有这些根管均与根尖周炎症反应相关。本研究中应用的方法未能对化学成分差异很大的牙髓材料进行敏感区分。