Mills Nikki, Anderson Brian J, Barber Colin, White Julian, Mahadevan Murali, Salkeld Leslie, Douglas Gavin, Brown Colin
Department of Pediatric Otolaryngology, Auckland Children's Hospital, Park Road, Auckland, New Zealand.
Int J Pediatr Otorhinolaryngol. 2004 Nov;68(11):1367-73. doi: 10.1016/j.ijporl.2004.04.009.
There is a controversy about day stay pediatric tonsillectomy in the UK and Australia. New Zealand has a similar health structure and we wished to compare day stay tonsillectomy from our hospital with those reported from other centers.
We performed a prospective audit of day stay tonsillectomy to determine conversion to hospital admission rate and the incidence of postoperative hemorrhage.
There were 4850 paediatric tonsillectomies performed with 80% of them as day stay procedures over a 9-year study period (1993-2002) in a university-affiliated tertiary children's hospital. The primary postoperative hemorrhage rate (within 24h of surgery) was 0.9% (CI 0.68-1.22%) and 83% occurred within the mandatory 4h postoperative observation period. Primary hemorrhage requiring re-operation to achieve hemostasis occurred in 18 children (0.37%, CI 0.2-0.54%). No child with a primary hemorrhage who presented after discharge following day stay surgery required re-operation or blood transfusion. Day stay surgery was planned in 4041 children and 4.7% (CI 4.1-5.4%) required conversion to hospital admission. Postoperative vomiting was the most common indication for conversion (2.65%, CI 2.2-3.1%), while hemorrhage contributed only 0.95% (CI 0.64-1.24%).
This study was performed in a health system similar to that of Australia and the UK. Complication and conversion rates are similar to those reported in North American centers. Pediatric day stay tonsillectomy is a safe procedure when performed with strict preoperative criteria, trained day stay unit (DSU) staff, and with in-patient facilities on site.
在英国和澳大利亚,日间小儿扁桃体切除术存在争议。新西兰有类似的医疗体系,我们希望将我院的日间扁桃体切除术与其他中心报告的情况进行比较。
我们对日间扁桃体切除术进行了前瞻性审计,以确定转为住院治疗的比率和术后出血的发生率。
在一所大学附属的三级儿童医院,在9年的研究期间(1993 - 2002年)共进行了4850例小儿扁桃体切除术,其中80%为日间手术。术后原发性出血率(术后24小时内)为0.9%(可信区间0.68 - 1.22%),83%发生在术后强制观察的4小时内。18名儿童(0.37%,可信区间0.2 - 0.54%)发生原发性出血,需要再次手术止血。日间手术后出院后出现原发性出血的儿童,无一例需要再次手术或输血。4041名儿童计划进行日间手术,4.7%(可信区间4.1 - 5.4%)需要转为住院治疗。术后呕吐是转为住院治疗最常见的原因(2.65%,可信区间2.2 - 3.1%),而出血仅占0.95%(可信区间0.64 - 1.24%)。
本研究是在与澳大利亚和英国类似的医疗体系中进行的。并发症和转为住院治疗的比率与北美中心报告的情况相似。当严格按照术前标准、由训练有素的日间手术单元(DSU)工作人员进行操作,并具备现场住院设施时,小儿日间扁桃体切除术是一种安全的手术。