Burman Marcia L, Kivlahan Daniel, Buchbinder Mara, Broglio Kristine, Zhou Xiao H, Merrill Joseph O, McDonell Mary B, Fihn Stephan D, Bradley Katharine A
Northwest Health Services Research and Development Center of Excellence, Veterans Affairs Puget Sound Health Care System, Seattle, Washington 98108-1597, USA.
J Stud Alcohol. 2004 Sep;65(5):621-30. doi: 10.15288/jsa.2004.65.621.
Most patients who misuse alcohol do not receive alcohol counseling from their providers. This study evaluated primary care patient and provider characteristics associated with receipt of alcohol-related advice and whether patients were advised to drink less or to abstain.
Outpatients from seven Veterans Affairs (VA) general medicine clinics were eligible if they screened positive for alcohol misuse, completed the Alcohol Use Disorders Identification Test (AUDIT) and answered questions about alcohol-related treatment and advice. Hierarchical logistic regression was used to evaluate patient and provider characteristics associated with patient reports of alcohol-related advice from a primary care provider in the past year.
Among 5191 patients with alcohol misuse in the past year, 1554 (30%) reported receiving alcohol-related advice from their primary care provider during that time. Of patients advised, 73% reported advice to abstain. The likelihood of reporting advice increased as AUDIT scores increased: from 13% of patients with AUDIT scores <8 to 71% of those with scores > or =20. After adjustment for important confounders, measures reflecting the severity of alcohol misuse were most strongly associated with receipt of alcohol-related advice. Adjusted analyses also revealed increased odds of receiving advice among patients who reported liver disease, hypertension, current smoking or continuity of care. No measured provider characteristic was associated with giving advice in the fully adjusted model.
This multisite VA study found that most patients with alcohol misuse did not receive alcohol counseling from a primary care provider. Moreover, providers predominantly offered advice to abstain, and they appeared to focus on patients with the most severe problems due to drinking or medical contraindications to drinking.
大多数滥用酒精的患者未从其医疗服务提供者处获得酒精咨询。本研究评估了与接受酒精相关建议相关的初级保健患者和提供者特征,以及患者是否被建议减少饮酒或戒酒。
来自七个退伍军人事务部(VA)普通内科诊所的门诊患者若酒精滥用筛查呈阳性、完成酒精使用障碍识别测试(AUDIT)并回答有关酒精相关治疗和建议的问题,则符合条件。采用分层逻辑回归来评估与过去一年中初级保健提供者给予酒精相关建议的患者报告相关的患者和提供者特征。
在过去一年中5191名酒精滥用患者中,1554名(30%)报告在此期间从其初级保健提供者处接受了酒精相关建议。在接受建议的患者中,73%报告被建议戒酒。随着AUDIT评分增加,报告接受建议的可能性也增加:从AUDIT评分<8的患者中的13%增加到评分≥20的患者中的71%。在对重要混杂因素进行调整后,反映酒精滥用严重程度的指标与接受酒精相关建议的关联最为强烈。调整后的分析还显示,报告患有肝病、高血压、当前吸烟或连续接受护理的患者接受建议的几率增加。在完全调整的模型中,未发现测量的提供者特征与提供建议有关。
这项多地点VA研究发现,大多数酒精滥用患者未从初级保健提供者处获得酒精咨询。此外,提供者主要提供戒酒建议,并且他们似乎将重点放在因饮酒或饮酒的医学禁忌症而存在最严重问题的患者身上。