Barr S I, Yarker K V, Levy-Milne R, Chapman G E
University of British Columbia, Vancouver, B.C., Canada.
J Hum Nutr Diet. 2004 Dec;17(6):503-12. doi: 10.1111/j.1365-277X.2004.00562.x.
To provide insight into Canadian dietitians' attitudes and practices regarding obesity and weight management.
Cross-sectional mail survey of a stratified random sample of members of Canadian dietetic associations.
A total of 514 dietitians (74% of those surveyed), 350 (69%) of whom actively counselled overweight/obese clients.
Participants received a questionnaire to assess dietitians' attitudes regarding obesity and overweight, views regarding their role in weight management, counselling practices, and the criteria used to judge success. Demographic variables were collected.
Most dietitians believed that obesity contributes to morbidity and mortality, and that small weight losses produced important health benefits. However, 80% agreed that health indicators other than weight loss should be the focus of obesity management, and 55% specifically recommended that clients not weigh themselves. Instead, weight management was promoted by recommending healthy eating and increased physical activity. Three-quarters agreed that they are the profession best trained to manage obesity but two-thirds believed their time would be better spent preventing rather than managing obesity. Dietitians most valued education received from on-the-job support and mentoring from other dietitians. Participants reported wanting to learn more about motivational and behavioural modification counselling techniques.
Canadian dietitians follow a lifestyle approach to weight management. Studies are required to formally assess the effectiveness of various aspects of this approach.
深入了解加拿大营养师对肥胖及体重管理的态度和做法。
对加拿大营养师协会成员分层随机抽样进行横断面邮寄调查。
共514名营养师(占被调查者的74%),其中350名(69%)积极为超重/肥胖客户提供咨询。
参与者收到一份问卷,以评估营养师对肥胖和超重的态度、对其在体重管理中作用的看法、咨询做法以及判断成功的标准。收集人口统计学变量。
大多数营养师认为肥胖会导致发病和死亡,且小幅体重减轻会带来重要的健康益处。然而,80%的人同意除体重减轻外的健康指标应成为肥胖管理的重点,55%的人特别建议客户不要称体重。相反,通过推荐健康饮食和增加体育活动来促进体重管理。四分之三的人同意他们是最有能力管理肥胖的专业人员,但三分之二的人认为将时间花在预防肥胖而非管理肥胖上会更好。营养师最看重在职支持和其他营养师的指导所获得的教育。参与者表示希望更多地了解动机和行为改变咨询技巧。
加拿大营养师采用生活方式方法进行体重管理。需要开展研究以正式评估该方法各个方面的有效性。