Featherstone Carolyn, Delaney Geoff, Jacob Susannah, Barton Michael
Collaboration for Cancer Outcomes Research and Evaluation, Liverpool Hospital, Sydney, New South Wales, Australia.
Cancer. 2005 Jan 15;103(2):393-401. doi: 10.1002/cncr.20755.
The objective of this study was to estimate the ideal proportion of new patients with leukemia and myeloma who should receive radiotherapy at some time during the course of their illness based on the best evidence.
Available evidence of the efficacy of radiotherapy in most clinical situations for leukemia and myeloma was identified through extensive literature reviews and treatment guideline searches. Epidemiologic data concerning the distribution of types, disease stages, and other factors that influence the use of radiotherapy were identified. Decision trees were constructed to merge the evidence-based recommendations with the epidemiological data to calculate the optimal proportion of patients who should receive radiotherapy according to the best available evidence. Actual radiotherapy utilization rates also were identified.
The proportion of patients diagnosed with myeloma in Australia who should receive radiotherapy based on the evidence was 38%. There was wide variation in the proportion of patients who actually received radiotherapy for myeloma from 24% up to 55%. The recommended proportion of patients diagnosed with myeloma in Australia who, according to the best available evidence, should receive at least a single course of radiotherapy was 38%. The proportion of patients diagnosed in Australia with leukemia who should receive radiotherapy at some point in their management, according to the best available evidence, was calculated at 4%, which corresponded with actual practice.
Further research will be required to determine why more patients who are diagnosed with myeloma are not treated with radiotherapy.
本研究的目的是根据最佳证据估计白血病和骨髓瘤新发病例在病程中某个阶段应接受放疗的理想比例。
通过广泛的文献综述和治疗指南检索,确定放疗在白血病和骨髓瘤大多数临床情况下疗效的现有证据。确定有关疾病类型分布、疾病分期以及影响放疗使用的其他因素的流行病学数据。构建决策树,将基于证据的建议与流行病学数据相结合,以根据现有最佳证据计算应接受放疗患者的最佳比例。还确定了实际放疗利用率。
根据证据,澳大利亚诊断为骨髓瘤的患者中应接受放疗的比例为38%。骨髓瘤患者实际接受放疗的比例差异很大,从24%到55%不等。根据现有最佳证据,澳大利亚诊断为骨髓瘤的患者中建议至少接受一个疗程放疗的比例为38%。根据现有最佳证据,澳大利亚诊断为白血病的患者在治疗过程中某个阶段应接受放疗的比例经计算为4%,这与实际情况相符。
需要进一步研究以确定为何更多诊断为骨髓瘤的患者未接受放疗。