Schutt Russell K, Weinstein Benjamin, Penk Walter E
Department of Sociology, University of Massachusetts, Boston, Massachusetts 02125, USA.
Psychiatr Serv. 2005 Mar;56(3):350-2. doi: 10.1176/appi.ps.56.3.350.
Previous research indicates that most homeless persons with mental illness prefer independent living, while most clinicians recommend group housing. This study compared residential preferences of 141 homeless veterans with dual diagnoses with those of 62 homeless nonveterans with dual diagnoses. Clinicians rated both groups while they were in transitional shelters before they were placed in housing. Both samples strongly rejected group home living, but a majority of nonveterans desired staff support. Clinicians recommended staffed group homes for most veterans and nonveterans. This survey underscores the disjuncture between consumers' and clinicians' preferences as well as the need to provide a range of housing options to accommodate varied preferences.
先前的研究表明,大多数患有精神疾病的无家可归者更喜欢独立生活,而大多数临床医生则推荐集体住房。本研究比较了141名患有双重诊断的无家可归退伍军人和62名患有双重诊断的无家可归非退伍军人的居住偏好。临床医生在两组人员被安置住房之前,于过渡性庇护所期间对他们进行了评估。两个样本都强烈拒绝集体家庭生活,但大多数非退伍军人希望得到工作人员的支持。临床医生为大多数退伍军人和非退伍军人推荐了配备工作人员的集体家庭。这项调查强调了消费者和临床医生偏好之间的脱节,以及提供一系列住房选择以适应不同偏好的必要性。