O'Reagain P J, Brodie J, Fraser G, Bushell J J, Holloway C H, Faithful J W, Haynes D
Department of Primary Industries and Fisheries, P.O. Box 976, Charters Towers, Queensland 4820, Australia.
Mar Pollut Bull. 2005;51(1-4):37-50. doi: 10.1016/j.marpolbul.2004.10.023. Epub 2004 Dec 8.
Increased sediment and nutrient losses resulting from unsustainable grazing management in the Burdekin River catchment are major threats to water quality in the Great Barrier Reef Lagoon. To test the effects of grazing management on soil and nutrient loss, five 1 ha mini-catchments were established in 1999 under different grazing strategies on a sedimentary landscape near Charters Towers. Reference samples were also collected from watercourses in the Burdekin catchment during major flow events. Soil and nutrient loss were relatively low across all grazing strategies due to a combination of good cover, low slope and low rainfall intensities. Total soil loss varied from 3 to 20 kg ha(-1) per event while losses of N and P ranged from 10 to 1900 g ha(-1) and from 1 to 71 g ha(-1) per event respectively. Water quality of runoff was considered moderate across all strategies with relatively low levels of total suspended sediment (range: 8-1409 mg l(-1)), total N (range: 101-4000 microg l(-1)) and total P (range: 14-609 microg l(-1)). However, treatment differences are likely to emerge with time as the impacts of the different grazing strategies on land condition become more apparent. Samples collected opportunistically from rivers and creeks during flow events displayed significantly higher levels of total suspended sediment (range: 10-6010 mg l(-1)), total N (range: 650-6350 microg l(-1)) and total P (range: 50-1500 microg l(-1)) than those collected at the grazing trial. These differences can largely be attributed to variation in slope, geology and cover between the grazing trial and different catchments. In particular, watercourses draining hillier, grano-diorite landscapes with low cover had markedly higher sediment and nutrient loads compared to those draining flatter, sedimentary landscapes. These preliminary data suggest that on relatively flat, sedimentary landscapes, extensive cattle grazing is compatible with achieving water quality targets, provided high levels of ground cover are maintained. In contrast, sediment and nutrient loss under grazing on more erodable land types is cause for serious concern. Long-term empirical research and monitoring will be essential to quantify the impacts of changed land management on water quality in the spatially and temporally variable Burdekin River catchment.
布尔迪肯河流域不可持续的放牧管理导致沉积物和养分流失增加,这对大堡礁泻湖的水质构成了重大威胁。为了测试放牧管理对土壤和养分流失的影响,1999年在查特斯堡附近的沉积地貌上,按照不同的放牧策略建立了5个1公顷的小型集水区。在主要水流事件期间,还从布尔迪肯集水区的水道采集了参考样本。由于植被覆盖良好、坡度低和降雨强度小,所有放牧策略下的土壤和养分流失都相对较低。每次事件的总土壤流失量在3至20千克/公顷之间,而氮和磷的流失量分别为每次事件10至1900克/公顷和1至71克/公顷。所有策略下径流的水质都被认为是中等的,总悬浮沉积物(范围:8 - 1409毫克/升)、总氮(范围:101 - 4000微克/升)和总磷(范围:14 - 609微克/升)的水平相对较低。然而,随着不同放牧策略对土地状况的影响变得更加明显,处理差异可能会随着时间的推移而出现。在水流事件期间从河流和小溪中随机采集的样本显示,总悬浮沉积物(范围:10 - 6010毫克/升)、总氮(范围:650 - 6350微克/升)和总磷(范围:50 - 1500微克/升)的水平明显高于在放牧试验中采集的样本。这些差异在很大程度上可归因于放牧试验集水区与不同集水区之间在坡度、地质和植被覆盖方面的差异。特别是,与排水较平坦的沉积地貌的水道相比,排水坡度较大、覆盖度低的花岗闪长岩地貌的水道沉积物和养分负荷明显更高。这些初步数据表明,在相对平坦的沉积地貌上,只要保持高水平的地面覆盖,广泛的牛群放牧与实现水质目标是相容的。相比之下,在更易侵蚀的土地类型上放牧造成的沉积物和养分流失令人严重担忧。长期的实证研究和监测对于量化土地管理变化对空间和时间变化的布尔迪肯河流域水质的影响至关重要。