Bennett Garrett H, Lessow Alexis, Song Phil, Constantinides Minas
Department of Otolaryngology, Division of Facial Plastic Surgery, New York University School of Medicine, New York, NY 10016, USA.
Arch Facial Plast Surg. 2005 Mar-Apr;7(2):94-7. doi: 10.1001/archfaci.7.2.94.
To statistically analyze the long-term results of alar base reduction after rhinoplasty.
Among a consecutive series of 100 rhinoplasty cases, 19 patients required alar base reduction. The mean (SD) follow-up time was 11 (9) months (range, 2 months to 3 years). Using preoperative and postoperative photographs, comparisons were made of the change in the base width (width of base between left and right alar-facial junctions), flare width (width on base view between points of widest alar flare), base height (distance from base to nasal tip on base view), nostril height (distance from base to anterior edge of nostril), and vertical flare (vertical distance from base to the widest alar flare). Notching at the nasal sill was recorded as none, minimal, mild, moderate, and severe.
Changes in vertical flare (P<.05) and nostril height (P<.05) were the only significant differences seen in the patients who required alar reduction. No significant change was seen in base width (P=.92), flare width (P=.41), or base height (P=.22). No notching was noted.
It would have been preferable to study patients undergoing alar reduction without concomitant rhinoplasty procedures, but this approach is not practical. To our knowledge, the present study represents the most extensive attempt in the literature to characterize and quantify the postoperative effects of alar base reduction.
对隆鼻术后鼻翼基底缩小的长期效果进行统计学分析。
在连续的100例隆鼻病例中,19例患者需要进行鼻翼基底缩小。平均(标准差)随访时间为11(9)个月(范围为2个月至3年)。利用术前和术后照片,比较了鼻基底宽度(左右鼻翼-面部交界处之间的基底宽度)、鼻翼张角宽度(在基底视图上鼻翼最宽处之间的宽度)、鼻基底高度(在基底视图上从基底到鼻尖的距离)、鼻孔高度(从基底到鼻孔前缘的距离)以及垂直张角(从基底到鼻翼最宽处的垂直距离)的变化。鼻槛处的切迹记录为无、轻微、轻度、中度和重度。
在需要进行鼻翼缩小的患者中,仅垂直张角(P<0.05)和鼻孔高度(P<0.05)有显著变化。鼻基底宽度(P = 0.92)、鼻翼张角宽度(P = 0.41)或鼻基底高度(P = 0.22)无显著变化。未观察到切迹。
研究未同时进行隆鼻手术的鼻翼缩小患者会更好,但这种方法不实用。据我们所知,本研究是文献中对鼻翼基底缩小术后效果进行特征描述和量化的最广泛尝试。