Sienaert Pascal, Bouckaert Filip, Milo Willy, Peuskens Joseph
ECT Department, University Center Sint-Jozef, Leuvensesteenweg, Kortenberg, Belgium.
J ECT. 2005 Mar;21(1):3-6. doi: 10.1097/01.yct.0000148622.26223.56.
We sought to review and describe the practice of electroconvulsive therapy (ECT) in Flanders and the Brussels Capital region, Belgium, in 2003.
A 30-item questionnaire was sent to all institutions that provided psychiatric care. Besides questions on training and general attitude toward ECT, most questions concerned technical aspects, quality, and organization of this treatment modality.
All psychiatric departments offering ECT and 58% of the hospitals that do not conduct ECT replied to the questionnaire. Forty-three percent of the departments offering ECT indicated less than 10 treatment sessions per month. Forty-three percent of hospitals set a fixed number of treatments per course. Maintenance ECT and ECT on an outpatient basis were rather rare, except for a few departments. The major indication for ECT was depression (88%) rather than schizophrenia (8%), mania (3%), or other psychiatric disorders (1%). Propofol was the anesthetic most commonly used (74%). Seven departments (30%) used a sine wave device. Bilateral electrode placement was the preferred option in 91% of all departments and both fixed high dose and dose titration strategy were used equally (both 47.8%).
The present findings demonstrate that the practice of ECT in Flanders and the Brussels Capital region in 2003 generally was not performed according to the available guidelines. ECT is underused in Flanders and the Brussels Capital region compared with other countries, although it is available in both specialized psychiatric facilities and in the psychiatric departments of general hospitals.
我们旨在回顾并描述2003年比利时弗拉芒大区和布鲁塞尔首都地区的电休克治疗(ECT)实践情况。
向所有提供精神科护理的机构发送了一份包含30个条目的问卷。除了关于ECT培训和总体态度的问题外,大多数问题涉及该治疗方式的技术方面、质量和组织情况。
所有提供ECT的精神科部门以及58%不进行ECT的医院回复了问卷。提供ECT的部门中有43%表示每月治疗次数少于10次。43%的医院为每个疗程设定了固定的治疗次数。维持性ECT和门诊ECT相当少见,只有少数部门除外。ECT的主要适应症是抑郁症(88%),而非精神分裂症(8%)、躁狂症(3%)或其他精神障碍(1%)。丙泊酚是最常用的麻醉剂(74%)。七个部门(30%)使用正弦波设备。在所有部门中,91%首选双侧电极放置,固定高剂量和剂量滴定策略的使用比例相同(均为47.8%)。
目前的研究结果表明,2003年弗拉芒大区和布鲁塞尔首都地区的ECT实践通常未按照现有指南进行。与其他国家相比,ECT在弗拉芒大区和布鲁塞尔首都地区未得到充分利用,尽管在专科医院和综合医院的精神科都可进行ECT。