Pirotte Benoit, Voordecker Philippe, Neugroschl Carine, Baleriaux Danielle, Wikler David, Metens Thierry, Denolin Vincent, Joffroy Alfred, Massager Nicolas, Brotchi Jacques, Levivier Marc
Department of Neurosurgery, Erasme Hospital, Université Libre de Bruxelles, Brussels, Belgium.
Neurosurgery. 2005 Apr;56(2 Suppl):344-59; discussion 344-59. doi: 10.1227/01.neu.0000144837.31665.29.
To evaluate, regardless of the clinical results, the contribution of combining functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) with intraoperative cortical brain mapping (iCM) as functional targeting methods for epidural chronic motor cortex stimulation (MCS) in refractory neuropathic pain.
Eighteen neuropathic pain patients (central stroke in six; trigeminal neuropathy in six; syrinx or amputation in six) who underwent operations for epidural MCS were studied with preoperative fMRI and iCM. fMRI investigated motor tasks of hands (as well as foot and tongue, when painful). fMRI data were analyzed with Statistical Parametric Mapping99 software (University College London, London, England; initial analysis threshold corresponding to P < 0.001), registered in a neuronavigation system, and correlated during surgery with iCM. The primary aim of this study was to improve the topographical precision of MCS. Matching of fMRI and iCM specifically was examined.
Correspondence between the contour of the fMRI activation area and iCM in precentral gyrus (mean distance, 3.8 mm) was found in 17 (94%) of 18 patients. Eleven of them showed correspondence for more restrictive values of the analysis threshold (P < 0.0001); in six patients, the quality of the iCM was reduced by somatosensory wave attenuation and general anesthesia. In this group of six patients, a combination of both techniques was used for the final targeting. Correspondence was not found in one patient as the result of image distortion and residual motion artifact. At follow-up (4-60 mo), MCS induced significant pain relief in a total of 11 patients (61%).
This study confirms the functional accuracy of fMRI guidance in neuropathic pain and illustrates the usefulness of combining fMRI guidance with iCM to improve the functional targeting in MCS. Because appropriate targeting is crucial to obtaining pain relief, this combination may increase the analgesic efficacy of MCS.
无论临床结果如何,评估将功能磁共振成像(fMRI)与术中皮质脑图谱(iCM)相结合作为难治性神经性疼痛硬膜外慢性运动皮质刺激(MCS)功能定位方法的作用。
对18例接受硬膜外MCS手术的神经性疼痛患者(6例为中枢性卒中;6例为三叉神经病变;6例为脊髓空洞症或截肢)进行术前fMRI和iCM研究。fMRI研究手部运动任务(疼痛时也研究足部和舌部)。使用统计参数映射99软件(英国伦敦大学学院;初始分析阈值对应P < 0.001)分析fMRI数据,将其注册到神经导航系统中,并在手术期间与iCM进行关联。本研究的主要目的是提高MCS的地形学精度。特别检查了fMRI和iCM的匹配情况。
18例患者中有17例(94%)在中央前回发现fMRI激活区域轮廓与iCM之间存在对应关系(平均距离为3.8 mm)。其中11例在更严格的分析阈值(P < 0.0001)下显示出对应关系;6例患者的iCM质量因体感波衰减和全身麻醉而降低。在这6例患者中,两种技术结合用于最终定位。1例患者由于图像失真和残余运动伪影未发现对应关系。在随访(4 - 60个月)时,MCS共使11例患者(61%)的疼痛得到显著缓解。
本研究证实了fMRI引导在神经性疼痛中的功能准确性,并说明了将fMRI引导与iCM相结合以改善MCS功能定位的有用性。由于合适的定位对于获得疼痛缓解至关重要,这种结合可能会提高MCS的镇痛效果。