Chibbaro S, Benvenuti L, Carnesecchi S, Marsella M, Serino D, Gagliardi R
Department of Neurosurgery, Livorno City Hospital, Livorno, Italy.
Acta Neurochir (Wien). 2005 Jul;147(7):735-9; discussion 739. doi: 10.1007/s00701-005-0522-6. Epub 2005 May 2.
The management of odontoid fractures represents both a clinical and a technical challenge due to the singular anatomy and biomechanics of the region. At present there is still much controversy as far as any form of management (surgical vs. conservative) is concerned and in any case there is not sufficient evidence to support a standardized form of treatment. This study was designed to further evaluate safety and efficacy of anterior odontoid single-screw fixation and to better determine the usefulness of Image Guided Surgery Virtual Fluoroscopy in treating such cases assessing also its advantages over traditional fluoroscopy and CT-guided frameless stereotaxy in the upper cervical spine surgery.
This was a retrospective review of ten patients presented during a short period of 18 months with acute traumatic Type II odontoid fractures. Nine underwent fixation within a mean of 3 days after injury, whereas a patient had to be operated upon on the 22nd day due to poor alignment with conservative treatment and ongoing instability. All patients postoperatively were fitted in a collar and then followed-up with serial clinical and radiographic examinations.
Radiological signs of fusion were seen in 10 cases (100%) (mean follow-up: 16 months). No complications occurred during the surgical procedure, nor were any instrumentation failures recorded; all patients remained neurologically intact.
We believe that anterior odontoid screw fixation using Image Guided Surgery virtual fluoroscopy is a safe, effective, less time consuming and low x-ray exposure technique and we recommend this as the preferred treatment method for acute Type II odontoid fractures. Moreover, the use of image guided technology affords more precision, confidence and safety enabling the surgeon to approach the upper cervical spine in an easier and faster way.
由于该区域独特的解剖结构和生物力学特性,齿状突骨折的治疗在临床和技术上均具有挑战性。目前,就任何形式的治疗(手术治疗与保守治疗)而言,仍存在诸多争议,而且无论如何都没有足够的证据支持标准化的治疗方式。本研究旨在进一步评估前路齿状突单螺钉固定的安全性和有效性,并更好地确定影像引导手术虚拟透视在治疗此类病例中的作用,同时评估其在上颈椎手术中相对于传统透视和CT引导无框架立体定向技术的优势。
这是一项对10例在18个月短时间内出现的急性创伤性II型齿状突骨折患者的回顾性研究。9例患者在受伤后平均3天内接受了固定,而1例患者因保守治疗后对位不佳且持续不稳定,在第22天接受了手术。所有患者术后均佩戴颈托,随后进行系列临床和影像学检查。
10例患者(100%)均出现融合的放射学征象(平均随访时间:16个月)。手术过程中未发生并发症,也未记录到任何器械故障;所有患者神经功能均保持完整。
我们认为,使用影像引导手术虚拟透视进行前路齿状突螺钉固定是一种安全、有效、耗时少且X线暴露量低的技术,我们推荐将其作为急性II型齿状突骨折的首选治疗方法。此外,影像引导技术的应用提供了更高的精确性、信心和安全性,使外科医生能够更轻松、快速地对上颈椎进行手术。