Matsui Hideaki, Udaka Fukashi, Oda Masaya, Kubori Tamotsu, Nishinaka Kazuto, Kameyama Masakuni
Department of Neurology, Sumitomo Hospital, 5-3-20 Nakanoshima, Kita-ku, Osaka 530-0005, Japan.
Auton Neurosci. 2005 Apr 29;119(1):56-60. doi: 10.1016/j.autneu.2005.03.003. Epub 2005 Apr 20.
We compared MIBG uptake at various parts of the body in controls and patients with Parkinson's disease and multiple system atrophy. In the heart, MIBG uptake in Parkinson's disease (early H/M: 1.668+/-0.325, late H/M: 1.500+/-0.402) was less than that in multiple system atrophy (early H/M: 2.395+/-0.186, late H/M: 2.530+/-0.391) and controls (early H/M: 2.635+/-0.508, late H/M: 2.575+/-0.635) (early: P<0.0001, late: P<0.0001). There were no significant differences in uptake by the lung, thyroid, or liver in the three groups. Only on early images, uptake in the shoulder in multiple system atrophy (early S/M: 0.473+/-0.78) and Parkinson's disease (early S/M: 0.470+/-0.710) was decreased compared to that in controls (early S/M: 0.560+/-0.118) (P=0.0252). MIBG is reported to be taken up in the terminal part of sympathetic nerves and demonstrates sympathetic nerve activity, especially on late images. The cause of differences between the heart and other parts of the body remains unknown. We consider the following possibilities: (a) differences in the sympathetic nervous system between Parkinson's disease and multiple system atrophy are more subtle in organs other than the heart; (b) the cause of MIBG uptake reduction by the heart in Parkinson's disease involves factors in addition to sympathetic nervous system damage; and (c) MIBG uptake by organs other than the heart involves not only the sympathetic nervous system but also non-neuronal components. In conclusion, MIBG uptake by organs other than the heart cannot differentiate Parkinson's disease from multiple system atrophy at present.
我们比较了对照组、帕金森病患者和多系统萎缩患者身体各部位的间碘苄胍(MIBG)摄取情况。在心脏方面,帕金森病患者的MIBG摄取(早期心脏与纵隔比值:1.668±0.325,晚期心脏与纵隔比值:1.500±0.402)低于多系统萎缩患者(早期心脏与纵隔比值:2.395±0.186,晚期心脏与纵隔比值:2.530±0.391)和对照组(早期心脏与纵隔比值:2.635±0.508,晚期心脏与纵隔比值:2.575±0.635)(早期:P<0.0001,晚期:P<0.0001)。三组在肺、甲状腺或肝脏的摄取方面无显著差异。仅在早期图像上,多系统萎缩患者(早期肩部与纵隔比值:0.473±0.78)和帕金森病患者(早期肩部与纵隔比值:0.470±0.710)肩部的摄取与对照组(早期肩部与纵隔比值:0.560±0.118)相比有所降低(P=0.0252)。据报道,MIBG在交感神经末梢被摄取,可显示交感神经活性,尤其是在晚期图像上。心脏与身体其他部位摄取差异的原因尚不清楚。我们考虑以下可能性:(a)帕金森病和多系统萎缩之间交感神经系统的差异在心脏以外的器官中更为细微;(b)帕金森病中心脏MIBG摄取减少的原因除了交感神经系统损伤外还涉及其他因素;(c)心脏以外器官的MIBG摄取不仅涉及交感神经系统,还涉及非神经元成分。总之,目前心脏以外器官的MIBG摄取无法区分帕金森病和多系统萎缩。
J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry. 1999-8
Ann Clin Transl Neurol. 2020-12
Clin Auton Res. 2018-7-30
Clin Auton Res. 2013-7-11
Clin Auton Res. 2011-7-27