Towprayoon S, Smakgahn K, Poonkaew S
Joint Graduate School of Energy and Environment, King Mongkut's University of Technology Thonburi, Thungkru, Bangkok 10140, Thailand.
Chemosphere. 2005 Jun;59(11):1547-56. doi: 10.1016/j.chemosphere.2005.02.009. Epub 2005 Mar 29.
One of the important cultural practices that affect methane and nitrous oxide emissions from tropical rice plantations is the water drainage system. While drainage can reduce methane emissions, it can also increase nitrous oxide emissions, as well as reduce yields. In this experiment, four different water drainage systems were compared in a rice field in central Thailand including: (1) continuous flooding, (2) mid-season drainage, (3) multiple drainage and (4) a local method (drainage was done according to local cultural practice) in order to find a system of drainage that would optimize yields while simultaneously limiting methane and nitrous oxide emissions. Methane and nitrous oxide emission were observed and compared with rice yield and physical changes of rice plants. It was found that drainage during the flowering period could reduce methane emission. Interestingly, nitrous oxide emission was related to number of drain days rather than the frequency of draining. Fewer drain days can help reduce nitrous oxide emission. The mid-season drainage and the multiple drainage, with 6.9% and 11.4% reduction in rice yield, respectively, had an average methane emission per crop 27% and 35% lower when compared to the local method. Draining with fewer drain days during the flowering period was recommended as a compromise between emissions and yield. The field drainage can be used as an option to reduce methane and nitrous oxide emissions from rice fields with acceptable yield reduction. Mid-season drainage during the rice flowering period, with a shortened drainage period (3 days), is suggested as a compromise between the need to reduce global warming and current socio-economic realities.
影响热带稻田甲烷和一氧化二氮排放的重要农业措施之一是排水系统。虽然排水可以减少甲烷排放,但也会增加一氧化二氮排放,并降低产量。在本实验中,泰国中部一块稻田对四种不同的排水系统进行了比较,包括:(1)持续淹水、(2)生育中期排水、(3)多次排水和(4)当地方法(根据当地农业习惯进行排水),目的是找到一种既能优化产量,又能同时限制甲烷和一氧化二氮排放的排水系统。对甲烷和一氧化二氮排放进行了观测,并与水稻产量及水稻植株的物理变化进行了比较。结果发现,花期排水可以减少甲烷排放。有趣的是,一氧化二氮排放与排水天数有关,而非排水频率。减少排水天数有助于降低一氧化二氮排放。生育中期排水和多次排水分别使水稻产量降低了6.9%和11.4%,与当地方法相比,每茬作物的平均甲烷排放量分别降低了27%和35%。建议在花期减少排水天数,作为排放与产量之间的折衷方案。田间排水可作为一种选择,在产量降低可接受的情况下减少稻田甲烷和一氧化二氮排放。建议在水稻花期进行生育中期排水,缩短排水期(3天),作为减少全球变暖需求与当前社会经济现实之间的折衷方案。