Coyne-Beasley Tamera, Baccaglini Lorena, Johnson Renee M, Webster Briana, Wiebe Douglas J
Department of Pediatrics, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill School of Medicine, Chapel Hill, NC 27599-7220, USA.
Pediatrics. 2005 Jun;115(6):e662-7. doi: 10.1542/peds.2004-2259.
The gender gap describing the apparent differences in male and female reports of firearm-ownership and -storage habits has never been evaluated among individuals who live in the same household. Thus, the objective of this study was to examine the level of agreement on household firearms and storage practices among cohabiting partners.
Data for this investigation came from follow-up telephone interviews of participants who underwent a randomized, controlled trial to test the effect of home-safety counseling, including firearm safety, on behavior change. Baseline interviews were conducted at a level 1 pediatric emergency department in North Carolina with adults who took a child or adolescent who was under his or her care to a pediatric emergency department. Follow-up interviews were conducted via telephone at 18 months after intervention with participants who reported household firearms at baseline. Participants then were asked whether their partners could be contacted for a separate telephone interview. The measured outcomes were number and type of household firearms and firearm-storage practices. The strength of agreement between partners' reported firearm-ownership and -storage practices was measured with the kappa statistic.
Seventy-six partner-respondent pairs completed the study (62% response rate). Most initial respondents were white (89%), female (76%), and college graduates (52%); the median age was 37. There were no same-gender partners, and 91% reported that they were spouses. There was not perfect agreement among male and female partners with regard to the presence of household firearms. More men (80%) reported the presence of household firearms than did women (72%; kappa = .64). The discordance between partner pairs regarding the number of household firearms and type was poor to fair (kappa = .35 and .34, respectively). Although similar proportions of men and women reported storing any household firearms loaded (10%) and storing all household firearms locked up (63% men and 62% women), the kappa values demonstrated only moderate agreement (kappa = .56-.60). Most men (88%) and women (83%) reported that firearm storage was the husband's responsibility; 82% of men compared with 17% of women reported that they personally owned all of the firearms.
A gender gap does exist in the reporting of firearm ownership with regard to the number and type of firearms owned. There are also differences in reported firearm-storage practices, which are likely related to the finding that men were reported to be the primary owner of firearms in most households as well as the person more commonly responsible for firearm storage. Firearm-safety counseling should include male partners in the history-taking process to improve knowledge about the presence and storage patterns of household firearms.
描述男女在枪支拥有和存放习惯报告中明显差异的性别差距,从未在同一家庭中的个体间进行过评估。因此,本研究的目的是检验同居伴侣在家庭枪支及存放做法上的一致程度。
本调查的数据来自对参与一项随机对照试验的参与者的随访电话访谈,该试验旨在测试包括枪支安全在内的家庭安全咨询对行为改变的影响。基线访谈在北卡罗来纳州一家一级儿科急诊科对带一名受其照料的儿童或青少年到儿科急诊科就诊的成年人进行。对在基线时报告家中有枪支的参与者,在干预后18个月通过电话进行随访访谈。然后询问参与者是否可以联系其伴侣进行单独的电话访谈。测量的结果是家庭枪支的数量和类型以及枪支存放做法。用kappa统计量衡量伴侣报告的枪支拥有和存放做法之间的一致强度。
76对伴侣 - 受访者完成了研究(回复率62%)。大多数初始受访者是白人(89%)、女性(76%)和大学毕业生(52%);年龄中位数为37岁。没有同性伴侣,91%报告他们是配偶。男女伴侣在家庭枪支是否存在方面没有完全一致的看法。报告家中有枪支的男性(80%)比女性(72%)多;kappa = 0.64。伴侣对在家庭枪支数量和类型方面的不一致程度为差到一般(kappa分别为0.35和0.34)。虽然报告家中有任何枪支上膛的男性和女性比例相似(10%),且报告将所有家庭枪支上锁的男性和女性比例也相似(男性63%,女性62%),但kappa值仅显示出中等程度的一致性(kappa = 0.56 - 0.60)。大多数男性(88%)和女性(83%)报告枪支存放是丈夫的责任;82%的男性与17%的女性报告他们个人拥有所有枪支。
在报告所拥有枪支的数量和类型方面确实存在性别差距。在报告的枪支存放做法上也存在差异,这可能与以下发现有关:在大多数家庭中,男性被报告为枪支的主要所有者,也是更常负责枪支存放的人。枪支安全咨询应在问诊过程中纳入男性伴侣,以提高对家庭枪支的存在情况和存放模式的了解。