Iversen Tor, Kopperud Gry Stine
Department of Health Management and Health Economics, University of Oslo, Oslo, Norway.
Health Econ. 2005 Dec;14(12):1231-8. doi: 10.1002/hec.1009.
In Norway specialized health services are provided both by public hospitals and by privately practicing specialists who have a contract with the public sector. A patient's co-payment is the same irrespective of the type of provider he visits. The ambition of equity in the allocation of medical care is high among all political parties. The instruments for auditing whether these goals are fulfilled are not equally ambitious. The objective of the present study is to explore whether laws and regulations that govern the allocation of specialist health care resources in fact are fulfilled. Panel data from the Survey of Living Conditions are merged with data on capacity and spatial access to primary and specialist care. We find that accessibility and socio-economic variables play a considerable role in determining both the probability of at least one visit and the number of visits to a private specialist. A person with a higher university degree living in a municipality with the highest value of the geographical accessibility index has a 46%-points higher probability of at least one visit to a private specialist compared with a person with junior high living in a municipality with the lowest value of the accessibility index. With regard to visits to a hospital outpatient department these variables are not found to have significant effects. We conclude that public ambitions and regulations are fulfilled for specialist services provided by public hospitals. With regard to the provision of services provided by publicly financed private specialists we find a discrepancy between public goals and surveyed practice.
在挪威,专科医院服务由公立医院以及与公共部门签订合同的私人执业专科医生提供。无论患者就诊的提供者类型如何,其自付费用都是相同的。所有政党在医疗保健分配方面实现公平的意愿都很高。用于审核这些目标是否实现的手段却没有同样高的意愿。本研究的目的是探讨管理专科医疗资源分配的法律法规实际上是否得到遵守。生活条件调查的面板数据与有关初级和专科护理的能力及空间可及性的数据相结合。我们发现,可及性和社会经济变量在决定至少就诊一次的概率以及去看私人专科医生的次数方面发挥着相当大的作用。与居住在地理可及性指数值最低的城市的初中文化程度者相比,居住在地理可及性指数值最高的城市的拥有更高大学学历的人去看私人专科医生至少一次的概率高出46个百分点。对于去医院门诊部就诊而言,未发现这些变量有显著影响。我们得出结论,公立医院提供的专科服务实现了公共意愿和规定。对于由公共资金资助的私人专科医生提供的服务,我们发现公共目标与调查实践之间存在差异。