Holroyd Kenneth A, Powers Scott W, Andrasik Frank
Department of Psychology, Ohio University, Athens 45701-2979, USA
Headache. 2005 May;45(5):487-92. doi: 10.1111/j.1526-4610.2005.05100.x.
Trials that compare drug and behavior therapies or evaluate combination therapy raise special methodological issues. This article reviews these methodological issues and, where possible, offers guidelines for addressing them. Sources of bias in the selection and recruitment of participants and in the measurement of treatment outcomes are discussed. In addition, methodological problems presented by the differing structures of behavior and drug therapy, by confounding variables, such as allegiance effects, differential expectations and preferences for drug or behavior therapy, and differential adherence with drug or behavior therapy also are reviewed. Issues in the selection of appropriate control groups are also discussed.
比较药物疗法和行为疗法或评估联合疗法的试验会引发特殊的方法学问题。本文回顾了这些方法学问题,并在可能的情况下提供解决这些问题的指导方针。讨论了在参与者的选择和招募以及治疗结果测量方面的偏倚来源。此外,还回顾了行为疗法和药物疗法不同结构所带来的方法学问题,以及诸如忠诚效应、对药物或行为疗法的不同期望和偏好,以及对药物或行为疗法的不同依从性等混杂变量。还讨论了选择合适对照组的问题。