Lin Xin-ping, Arild Stenvik
Department of Orthodontics, School of Stomatology, Wenzhou Medical College, China.
Shanghai Kou Qiang Yi Xue. 2005 Jun;14(3):238-42.
The aim of this study was to investigate the stability and reproducibility of natural head position (NHP) in adolescents with three different facial types.
The material consisted of intact lateral cephalograms of 30 male subjects and 30 female subjects, taken at 6, 9, 12, 15, 18 years in NHP. These subjects were selected randomly and divided into three groups based on the MP-SN angle at approximately 15 years of age. Serial cephalometric roentgenograms traced upon the superimposition method based on the "best fit" of anterior cranial base structures. The changes of NSL/VER angulation were analyzed statistically.
The standard deviation of the NSL/VER angulation at 6 year occasion, the mean incremental values, the standard deviation and the method error of NSL/VER angulation during the period from 6 years occasion to any other occasion were larger, the coefficient of reliability was much more lower than the others. The standard deviation and the mean incremental values among 9-year, 12-year, 15-year and 18-year occasions were lower. The coefficient of reliability range from 76% to 97% and the method error at these six periods ranged from 1.84 degrees to 3.48 degrees in three facial types. There was different natural head position in three different facial types with cross-sectional comparison. The angulation in LFT was significantly larger than AFT and HFT, and the values in HFT were the smallest. However, there were no significantly statistical differences in three facial types as the change magnitude of NHP over time was compared.
These suggest that the NHP of children at 6 years occasion or during the period from 6 years to 9 years of age is highly variable and this situation should be paid attention on while the facial growth studies and the cephalometric radiogram are made. The variance of NHP during any periods from 9 years to 18 years of age in three facial types (3.4 degrees to 12.1 degrees ) is much more less than the variance of intracranial reference planes to the vertical (25 degrees to 36 degrees ). Cephalometric analyses upon NHP in different facial types among these four occasional radiograms are rather highly valid. Supported by Research Fund (No.300411) from Zhejiang Province.
本研究旨在调查三种不同面部类型青少年自然头位(NHP)的稳定性和可重复性。
材料包括30名男性和30名女性受试者完整的侧位头影测量片,在6、9、12、15、18岁时于自然头位下拍摄。这些受试者随机选取,并根据约15岁时的MP-SN角分为三组。基于前颅底结构的“最佳拟合”,采用叠加法对系列头影测量X线片进行描图。对NSL/VER角度的变化进行统计学分析。
6岁时NSL/VER角度的标准差、6岁至其他任何时间点NSL/VER角度的平均增加值、标准差和方法误差较大,可靠性系数远低于其他情况。9岁、12岁、15岁和18岁时的标准差和平均增加值较低。三种面部类型在这六个时期的可靠性系数范围为76%至97%,方法误差范围为1.84度至3.48度。横断面比较显示三种不同面部类型的自然头位不同。低角面型(LFT)的角度明显大于均角面型(AFT)和高角面型(HFT),高角面型的值最小。然而,比较三种面部类型自然头位随时间的变化幅度时,无显著统计学差异。
这些结果表明,6岁时或6至9岁期间儿童的自然头位高度可变,在进行面部生长研究和头影测量X线检查时应予以关注。三种面部类型在9岁至18岁任何时期自然头位的方差(3.4度至12.1度)远小于颅内参考平面与垂直方向的方差(25度至36度)。这四张不同时期X线片上不同面部类型自然头位的头影测量分析具有较高的效度。由浙江省科研基金(编号300411)资助。