Tan Patrick, Marotta Paul, Ghent Cameron, Adams Paul
Division of Gastroenterology, Department of Medicine, London Health Sciences Centre, London, ON, Canada.
Liver Int. 2005 Aug;25(4):728-33. doi: 10.1111/j.1478-3231.2005.01121.x.
The need for immunosuppression in autoimmune hepatitis is established. Previous studies have investigated short-term outcomes in patients who respond to treatment. This study assesses long-term prognosis of patients who fail to respond to standard immunosuppression.
163 charts were reviewed, composed of 108 non-transplant patients and 55 patients who required liver transplantation (LT). Clinical endpoints were based on aminotransaminases: early treatment response (ER) was a 50% improvement at 6 months of therapy, Complete remission (CR) was an improvement to <2X normal, Relapse was worsening to >3X normal, Incomplete response (IR) was some response but no CR in 3 years, and No response (NR) was no improvement after 3 years.
85% of non-LT and 25% of LT patients achieved ER, 91% of non-LT and 26% of LT patients achieved CR. 41% of non-LT patients relapsed on maintenance treatment, and 41% of non-LT patients relapsed when withdrawn from treatment. 9% of non-LT and 58% of LT patients had IR. 16% in LT group showed NR, while all non-LT patients showed some response. All paired comparisons were statistically different (P<0.05). Multiple regression analysis revealed that lack of ER predicts need for LT (P=0.0005). 87% of patients who achieved ER did not require LT, whereas 16% of patients who failed ER showed NR and all required LT. Odds ratio of a patient who failed ER proceeding to LT, compared to a patient who achieved ER, was 16.8 (7.5 to 37.7, 95% CI).
Patients who fail to show a 50% improvement in transaminases at 6 months of standard immunosuppression should be considered for alternate treatment modalities or be referred earlier for LT.
自身免疫性肝炎患者需要进行免疫抑制治疗,这一点已得到公认。以往的研究调查了对治疗有反应的患者的短期预后。本研究评估了对标准免疫抑制治疗无反应的患者的长期预后。
回顾了163份病历,其中包括108例非移植患者和55例需要肝移植(LT)的患者。临床终点基于转氨酶:早期治疗反应(ER)定义为治疗6个月时改善50%,完全缓解(CR)定义为改善至<正常上限2倍,复发定义为恶化至>正常上限3倍,不完全反应(IR)定义为有一定反应但3年内未达到CR,无反应(NR)定义为3年后无改善。
85%的非LT患者和25%的LT患者达到ER,91%的非LT患者和26%的LT患者达到CR。41%的非LT患者在维持治疗期间复发,41%的非LT患者在停药时复发。9%的非LT患者和58%的LT患者有IR。LT组中16%的患者显示NR,而所有非LT患者均有一定反应。所有配对比较均有统计学差异(P<0.05)。多元回归分析显示,未达到ER预示需要进行LT(P=0.0005)。达到ER的患者中有87%不需要LT,而未达到ER的患者中有16%显示NR且均需要LT。与达到ER的患者相比,未达到ER的患者进行LT的比值比为16.8(7.5至37.7,95%CI)。
在标准免疫抑制治疗6个月时转氨酶未改善50%的患者,应考虑采用其他治疗方式或更早转诊进行LT。