Peterson Cathryn A, Tucker Richard P
Department of Physical Therapy, University of the Pacific, Stockton, California, USA.
Clin Anat. 2005 Oct;18(7):540-7. doi: 10.1002/ca.20154.
The performance of students taking medical gross anatomy at the University of California at Davis during a 4-year period (1999-2002) was correlated with prior undergraduate anatomy coursework. Significant correlations were observed between class rank in medical anatomy and taking any undergraduate anatomy as well as the total number of undergraduate anatomy units (P<0.01). Taking human gross anatomy and an anatomy laboratory course were significantly correlated with medical anatomy class rank (P<0.01) as were grades in human anatomy, comparative vertebrate anatomy and anatomy laboratory courses (P<0.05). The medical anatomy course offered in 1999-2000 was 172 hr long, and the course offered in 2001-2002 was 135 hr long, with most of the difference made by decreasing lecture time while sparing the dissection laboratory. The reduction in course length was the consequence of a curriculum-wide cap in weekly contact hours. In the 172-hr medical anatomy course there were significant correlations between the students who took undergraduate anatomy and both class rank and the score on the final examination (P<0.01). These correlations did not exist for the 135-hr course. This may be explained by previous anatomy experiences helping students learn from lecture more than from dissection laboratory, as well as the extra study time available to students in the reformed medical curriculum. Pre-medical students and health science advisors need to consider that the benefits of taking anatomy as an undergraduate may be dependent on the configuration of a medical school's curriculum.
加利福尼亚大学戴维斯分校的学生在四年期间(1999 - 2002年)医学大体解剖学课程的表现与之前本科阶段的解剖学课程作业相关。医学解剖学课程排名与是否修读过任何本科解剖学课程以及本科解剖学课程的总学分数之间存在显著相关性(P<0.01)。修读过人体大体解剖学和解剖学实验课程与医学解剖学课程排名显著相关(P<0.01),人体解剖学、比较脊椎动物解剖学和解剖学实验课程的成绩也与之显著相关(P<0.05)。1999 - 2000年开设的医学解剖学课程时长为172小时,2001 - 2002年开设的课程时长为135小时,时长差异主要源于减少了讲座时间,同时保留了解剖实验室时间。课程时长的减少是整个课程体系对每周接触时长进行限制的结果。在172小时的医学解剖学课程中,修读过本科解剖学课程的学生与课程排名和期末考试成绩之间存在显著相关性(P<0.01)。而在135小时的课程中,这些相关性并不存在。这可能是因为之前的解剖学学习经历帮助学生从讲座中学习的效果超过了解剖实验室,同时改革后的医学课程体系也为学生提供了额外的学习时间。医学预科学生和健康科学顾问需要考虑到,本科阶段修读解剖学的益处可能取决于医学院课程体系的设置。