McCann Joyce C, Ames Bruce N
Nutrition, Metabolism and Genomics Center, Children's Hospital Oakland Research Institute, Oakland, CA 94609, USA.
Am J Clin Nutr. 2005 Aug;82(2):281-95. doi: 10.1093/ajcn.82.2.281.
This review is part of a series intended for nonspecialists that will summarize evidence relevant to the question of whether causal relations exist between micronutrient deficiencies and brain function. Here, we focus on experiments that used cognitive or behavioral tests as outcome measures in experimental designs that were known to or were likely to result in altered brain concentrations of the n-3 fatty acid docosahexaenoic acid (DHA) during the perinatal period of "brain growth spurt." Experimental designs reviewed include observational breastfeeding studies and randomized controlled trials in humans and studies in rodents and nonhuman primates. This review is based on a large number of expert reviews and commentaries and on some 50 recent studies in humans and animals that have not yet been included in published reviews. Expert opinion regarding the strengths and weaknesses of the major experimental systems and uncertainties associated with interpreting results is summarized. On the basis of our reading of this literature, we conclude that evidence from several types of studies, particularly studies in animals, suggests that, within the context of specific experimental designs, changes in brain concentrations of DHA are positively associated with changes in cognitive or behavioral performance. Additional experimental information required to conclude that a causal association exists is discussed, as are uncertainties associated with applying results from specific experimental designs to the question of whether infant formula should be supplemented with DHA.
本综述是面向非专业人士的系列综述的一部分,旨在总结与微量营养素缺乏和脑功能之间是否存在因果关系这一问题相关的证据。在此,我们重点关注在“脑发育激增”围产期已知或可能导致大脑中n-3脂肪酸二十二碳六烯酸(DHA)浓度改变的实验设计中,将认知或行为测试作为结果指标的实验。所综述的实验设计包括人类的观察性母乳喂养研究和随机对照试验,以及啮齿动物和非人类灵长类动物的研究。本综述基于大量专家综述和评论,以及约50项近期尚未纳入已发表综述的人类和动物研究。总结了关于主要实验系统的优缺点以及与结果解释相关的不确定性的专家意见。基于我们对这些文献的研读,我们得出结论,来自多种类型研究的证据,尤其是动物研究表明,在特定实验设计的背景下,大脑中DHA浓度的变化与认知或行为表现的变化呈正相关。讨论了得出存在因果关联所需的其他实验信息,以及将特定实验设计的结果应用于婴儿配方奶粉是否应添加DHA这一问题时的不确定性。